Toronto Jumps the Line: Lottery Hands Blue Jays No. 1 Pick in Slugger-Rich Class
By Dugout News Desk
The Blue Jays leapfrogged Nashville to claim the top pick, and the class is stacked with power bats. Here's who might go where, plus the sleepers worth circling.
The Lottery: Toronto Cashes In
Somebody in Toronto bought a very lucky ticket. The Blue Jays, who limped to 64-98 and entered the lottery with the fourth-best odds, won the No. 1 pick in the 2198 ML Rookie Draft. GM xkyleactivex now holds the first selection in a class that, as we'll see, is loaded with thunder.
The real loser is Nashville. The Stars went 54-108, the worst record in the league by five games, and had the best lottery position. They slid to No. 2. That is hardly a tragedy, but it is a reminder that being the worst team in baseball does not guarantee the top spot. Still, Nashville picks second and gets a premium bat or arm for a roster the Power Rankings list dead last.
Ottawa made the biggest climb among the top five, jumping from fifth to third after a 65-97 season. Texas (also 65-97) landed at No. 4, moving up from sixth. San Francisco (67-95) went from seventh to fifth, and Minnesota (71-91) rose from eighth to sixth. Not a bad night for the middle of the lottery pack.
Now the teams that went the wrong way. Detroit, which lost 103 games, had the second-best odds and fell all the way to No. 7. The Yankees, at 60-102 the third-worst team in the league, dropped from third to eighth. Both clubs are staring at long rebuilds, and falling five spots stings. San Diego fell from ninth to twelfth, and Vancouver slid from thirteenth to fourteenth, with Washington sneaking up from fourteenth to thirteenth.
Rounding out the lottery: Miami at No. 9 (moved down from tenth in the odds order... actually up one, from tenth to ninth), Anaheim at 10, and Colorado at 11. The Angels picked up an unfortunate bit of news in the same sim, as starter Ernesto Domínguez will miss about ten months with a torn labrum suffered while showing off on his motorcycle. Anaheim's pitching depth just got thinner, which makes a high pick that much more interesting. The draft takes place on Sunday, June 10, 2198.
The Shape of the Class: Power, Power, and More Power
The Dugout's board for this class is dominated by sluggers. Nearly every top hitter has power potential of 75 or 80 and an eye grade of 70 or better. The flip side: a lot of them come with poor contact and strikeout-avoidance grades. This is a class of three-true-outcomes bats, and whoever drafts them should be ready for plenty of walks, homers, and swings and misses.
We'll break it into tiers.
Tier 1: The Big Four. Doug Williams, Steve Chapman, David Fox, and Joe Collins sit within about two and a half points of each other, from 67.7 down to 65.3 in potential.
Tier 2: High-ceiling projects. Brian McNeill, Andre Thomas, Daniel Alipaz, Ron Proctor, Alonso Castaneda Jr., and Ryan O'Neal, all between 62.7 and 65.0. Several are 17 and years away.
Tier 3: The rest of the first round. Alex James, Taylor Jones, Sean Huggins, Brian La, and company, in the low 60s.
The Top Ten, Profiled
1. Doug Williams, 1B, age 22. The board's top prospect has 75 power and an elite 80 eye, with 55 contact and 55 avoid K. He is the most complete bat in the class, and at 48.7 now, he is also close to big-league ready. The risks: his work ethic is low, and he runs at a 2 speed, so he is a first baseman and nothing else. Think middle-of-the-order hitter who needs a nudge to keep working.
2. Steve Chapman, RF, age 22. Power 80, eye 80, gap 80: that is a monster. But the avoid K grade is a miserable 30 and contact is only 45, so he could strike out a lot. Work ethic and intelligence are both high, which helps. He is 44.0 now, so he needs some time. A lefty slugger with huge upside and a real bust risk.
3. David Fox, SS, age 21. The most big-league ready of the top group at 52.9 now, which is already above average. He is a shortstop with 80 power and 80 eye, though the contact (45) and avoid K (30) are shaky. If he sticks at short, he is potentially the most valuable player in the class. High work ethic is a plus.
4. Joe Collins, RF, age 21. Lefty bat with 80 power and 80 eye, 60 gap. Very similar to Chapman but a little less gap power, and a normal makeup. He is 43.8 now, so expect a development curve.
5. Brian McNeill, 1B, age 17. The youngest bat in the top five. Power 80, eye 70, contact 50, avoid K 45, so a more balanced profile than the others. But he is 30.5 now, low intelligence, and years from the majors. A pure upside pick.
6. Andre Thomas, CF, age 21. Power 75, eye 80, gap 70, and the best speed (7) of the top group, with a center field glove. Contact is 40 and avoid K 30, so the strikeouts will be there. A rare power-and-speed combination.
7. Daniel Alipaz, SP, age 17. The top arm on the board. Movement 70 and control 75 are strong, but stuff is only 35 and velocity is 87-89. A finesse pitcher with high intelligence. He is 36.2 now, so patience is required.
8. Ron Proctor, SP, age 18. Movement 70, control 70, velocity 92-94, with stuff at 40. A step up in velocity from Alipaz, and high intelligence as well. A safer, more conventional starter profile.
9. Alonso Castaneda Jr., 1B, age 17. Power 75 and a balanced 50 contact, 50 avoid K, high intelligence. He is 33.5 now, a long-term project.
10. Ryan O'Neal, C, age 17. A switch-hitting catcher with 75 eye, 65 power, 65 gap, and 50 contact. Catchers with real bats are scarce, and his high intelligence is a bonus behind the plate. He is 35.3 now, so he is a long wait.
Sleepers Worth Circling
Dave Knell (RP, 22). His stuff grade is 75 with 94-96 velocity, and he is already 45.5. The control (45) is a question, but he could be a bullpen arm quickly and a cheap one.
Martin Wilson (SS, 21). Only 61.1 in potential, but he is already 49.9 now, with high work ethic and intelligence and a balanced 55 contact, 55 avoid K, 75 eye. A safe pick.
Brian La (SP, 18). Stuff 60 and a 96-98 fastball, the hardest thrower on the board, with a switch-hitting bat to boot. Control at 55 is workable. Do not be surprised if he outperforms his No. 14 ranking.
Taylor Jones (SP, 18). The best combined stuff and movement among the pitchers outside the top ten, 94-96 velocity.
Harry Lund (CF, 18). Gap 80 and speed 9, with an unusual blend of tools, even if he is only 28.5 right now.
Deepest Positions
First base is the deepest spot, with Williams, McNeill, Castaneda, and Steve Jones all in the top 25. Center field is a close second with Thomas, James, Colter, and Lund. Right field offers Chapman, Collins, Hathaway, and Camacho. Catcher and second base are thin: O'Neal and Flynn are the only catchers, and Huggins is the lone second baseman. Pitching is thin at the very top, though there are quality arms in the teens.
Who Might Take Whom
This is opinion, not a forecast. Toronto, at No. 1, probably chooses between Williams, the safest bat, and Fox, the shortstop. Williams is closest to ready, and Fox has the positional value. We lean Williams.
Nashville at No. 2 has a roster that needs everything. Fox or Chapman would be a natural fit, and either would be a massive upgrade. Ottawa at No. 3 could take whichever of the Big Four is left, and Texas at No. 4 gets the last of them. San Francisco at No. 5 might gamble on the youth of McNeill or take Thomas, while Minnesota at No. 6 could look at the arms.
Detroit at No. 7 and the Yankees at No. 8, both sliding, may be the ones who benefit most from the pitching depth, with Alipaz and Proctor likely to come off the board in that range. Either would be a fair consolation for missing the top five.