The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Opening Day predictions · Apr 1, 2198

Opening Day 2198: Boston Is the Team to Beat, but the Maps Disagree

By Dugout News Desk

Boston tops both the Dugout's rankings and the game's projections, but Tampa Bay, Colorado and the Angels have the two systems arguing. Our season preview picks a side and makes bold calls.

Opening Day is here, and the numbers have already started the arguments. The Dugout's Preseason Prediction Rankings are built mostly on WAA for each team's best 26 players, plus roster strength, depth and offseason moves. The game's own projections, from the Commish's screenshots, come from a sim of the whole season. Where they agree, bank it. Where they don't, that's where the fun is.

The Favorites

Boston Red Sox are number one in our rankings (68.2, projected 103-59) and the game has them at 108-54, the best record in baseball by a wide margin. They were 106-56 last year, rank first in roster strength and depth, and open at Nashville. The offseason cost them Dave Harper and a pair of infielders, and our Net WAR added column grumbles about it (-9.7). Nobody else is close enough for that to matter much.

Cincinnati Reds are number two (66.2, 100-62), and the game agrees they win the AL Aaron at 91-71. Baltimore Orioles round out our top three at 95-67 behind the number one rotation in the league. The game has them winning the NL Clemente, but only at 86-76. Houston Astros and Tampa Bay Devil Rays are projected to tie at 91-71 in the NL Gibson.

Where the Two Systems Disagree

The biggest gap is Tampa Bay. We have them 12th, with a roster strength rank of 31st and a rotation ranked 35th, after losing Clifton Ward, Michael Ash and Tony Gaston. The game has them tied for the best record in the NL. Their 98-64 season last year plus the number four depth ranking suggests the game is leaning on a deep system. I'm leaning toward our side, but I wouldn't bet the house.

Colorado Rockies are the other one. The game sees 93-69 and a runner-up spot in the AL Ruth. We rank them 21st, at 79-83. They lost 86 games last year and the offseason subtracted more than it added. I don't buy it, and Del Blankenbeckler's torn labrum won't help the pitching.

On the flip side, the game is cold on the Mets (86-76, second in the NL Mays) while we have them fourth overall at 93-69. They were 83-79 last year and have a top-five rotation. I'm with us. Same with the Angels, who we like a bit more than the game's 80-82.

Sleepers and Dark Horses

Washington Nationals are the best sleeper. The game has them winning the AL Robinson at 90-72, and we rank them 10th after they added Michael Ash and Fred Lowe. That's a 78-84 team from a year ago. Ash starts their opener against the Cubs.

Vancouver Evergreens added the most Net WAR in our rankings of any contender, +8.3, including Steve Wright. Their roster strength still ranks 28th, so they're a classic projection-versus-reality gamble. Texas Rangers (+8.6) and Toronto Blue Jays (+10.3, the biggest haul in the league) bought hard. Toronto, though, is still coming off 64 wins and the game projects 70-92.

Rebuilding, Politely Speaking

San Francisco Giants are last in our rankings (65-97) and the game gives them just 62 wins, the worst number in the league. The silver lining is Mark Poholsky, the number one prospect on the new BNN Top 100 list. Nashville Stars (68-94 by our math) also have to look to the future after a 54-108 season, as do the Minnesota Twins. San Antonio Scorpions added nobody and open with the lowest score in the middle of the pack of ranks at 66-96. Sorry, Jmustang. That's hard to watch.

Bold Predictions

1. Boston wins 100 games, and I'll say more than that: the Red Sox take the best record in baseball.
2. Tampa Bay lands between our number and the game's number, somewhere around 88 wins, and still makes October.
3. Washington beats the game's own forecast and takes the AL Robinson by more than two games.
4. Colorado falls well short of 93 wins. Call it 82 or fewer.
5. San Francisco avoids the worst record in baseball. Somebody, probably Nashville or Minnesota, will be worse.

Play ball.