The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Front Office column · Apr 11, 2198

Tampa Bay Spends Big, San Diego Wins Cheap, and Everyone Else Waits

By Dana Whitlock

The Devil Rays carry the league's biggest payroll and keep shopping. The Padres, with the smallest, are 7-2. Dana Whitlock asks what all of it costs.

Welcome to the part of the season where the checkbooks come out. Three stories matter this month.

Tampa Bay Writes Checks

The Tampa Bay Devil Rays lead the league at $181.8M in 2198 payroll, and Brock is still shopping. In the last week Tampa Bay signed Tony Gaston ($5.2M), Trevor Parker ($8.1M) and Tom Mitchell ($7.0M), all one-year deals. On Apr 11 the club also added 3B Makoto Nakashima from Colorado, C John Moore from Boston and SP Tim Muñóz from the Mets. That is a lot of rentals. The Devil Rays are only 5-4, though José Reyes was NL Player of the Week, and the club sits sixth in the Power Rankings. My view: this is a win-now bet on a division the Devil Rays lead by two games at most, and it lands on a ledger that already shows 10 free agents and 4 arbitration cases after the season. Committed money for 2199 is $126.5M, so the bill is coming either way. Brock is spending like a man who believes in October, and I'd like to see more than a 5-4 start before I call it genius.

San Diego Does It the Cheap Way

Here is the counterpoint. The San Diego Padres have the lowest payroll in the league at $76.4M, and they are 7-2 with the second-best Power mark. They have only $31.0M committed for 2199 and one free agent coming off the books. Rschwep is running the most efficient shop in baseball, and he is doing it while closer Franklin Lewis is out 123 days. Sooner or later a payroll this small tends to meet a bullpen this thin, so watch it. The Oakland Athletics are the other thrifty winner at $87.1M, and they're 6-3 even after adding Dan Robinson and Paco Rodríguez on modest one-year money.

The Mets' Bill

The New York Mets sit at $180.0M, second only to Tampa Bay, and are 5-4 with a Pythagorean mark of 4-5. Anthony's club has 8 arbitration cases after the year, plus a 37-year-old Jeremy Simmons at $2.2M that some fans questioned. Paying near-top dollar for a middle-of-the-pack record is the kind of math I like to circle in red.

What to Watch

By my next column, see whether Tampa Bay's spending shows up in the standings, and whether the cheap Padres hold their pace. The Colorado Rockies ($147.9M, 3-6) deserve a look: if the slide continues, expect sellers' talk. The Detroit Tigers, 2-7 at $77.1M, only just swapped Todd Duncan in a deal, so they are another team to check back on.