The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Apr 11, 2198

Giants Sit 4-5 With One Great Bat, One Great Arm, and Chase Morris's 14.09 ERA

By Grace Liu

Michael Martin is hitting .500 and Gus Bush hasn't allowed a run, yet San Francisco is 4-5. Grace Liu on the Giants' one-man offense and the $78M question in the rotation.

Last column I left the Giants with a big arm and a lineup of .208 hitters. Nine games in, the arm is in trouble and the lineup has one genuine star. San Francisco is 4-5, two games behind Oakland in AL Aaron, and ranked 33rd in the Power Rankings. That's 41.6 Power, ahead of only Montreal, Cleveland and Detroit.

The Martin Show

First baseman Michael Martin is the reason this team isn't worse. He's hitting .500 with 3 home runs, 6 RBI and a 1.423 OPS, and his 0.9 WAR puts him fourth among all hitters in the league. Nobody else on the roster has topped 0.2.

The supporting cast is thin. Second baseman Jorge Sánchez is at .154 with no RBI in nine games. Right fielder Keith Richert is at .121 with a .303 OPS, which is the sort of line that makes a spreadsheet cry. Richert's -0.4 WAR is the worst on the club. Catcher Michael Moryn is hitting .238 with one RBI. One bat can't carry a lineup for 162 games. I'd like to see manager lineup cards give Mark McGinnis (.300, .862 OPS, 2 steals in five games) and James Gilmore (.900 OPS) more at-bats.

The $78M Problem

Then there's Chase Morris, the $78M man. He's 0-2 with a 14.09 ERA across 7.2 innings, and he's scheduled to start Apr. 13 against the Albuquerque Blues, who are 7-2. Two starts is a tiny sample, but GM LighttheWick has made it a big one by paying him like an ace.

The pitching has bright spots. Gus Bush hasn't allowed a run in 10.1 innings and has 14 strikeouts. He is oddly listed with zero starts, so he's working as a weapon out of the bullpen. Brian Gates has a 1.50 ERA and six strikeouts in his one start. The bullpen is shakier. Tony Brown has a 9.64 ERA and closer Héctor Herrera is at 5.40, though he does have 2 saves.

The Roster Purge

On Apr. 11 the club sent a long list of players to the minors, including outfielder Mark Poholsky, the system's top prospect. Reliever Juan Valdés also left for the New York Mets. That reads like a roster trim, not a rebuild, but the farm will matter if this lineup doesn't wake up.

What to watch

The schedule is rough. The Giants visit Albuquerque from Apr. 11-13, host the Padres (7-2) and then Oakland (6-3) in the following week. If Morris and Martin stay as they are, the Giants could be in the cellar by my next column. The question is whether anyone besides Martin starts hitting, and whether Morris gets his ERA below double digits before May.