The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Apr 11, 2198

Cleveland's Champions Stumble to 2-7 and the Pitching Is Why

By Nadia Kovac

The World Series sweepers sit last in AL Robinson at 2-7, with a rotation that can't hold a lead and a shortstop who can't find the ball. Nadia Kovac on what's fixable.

My last column warned that the Guardians were champions on paper and a thin-margin contender in the numbers. Nine games in, the margin has gone negative. Cleveland is 2-7, four games back in AL Robinson, and 35th of 36 in the Power Rankings, down 17 places. Only Detroit ranks lower in the Dugout Power Index.

The rotation is the whole story

The Pythagorean record says 3-6, so this isn't pure bad luck. It's mostly arms. Joshua Ford has allowed a 15.88 ERA over 5.2 innings in two starts, and Bob Ward sits at 6.55. Paul Long is at 5.40, though he leads the league with 18 strikeouts in 11.2 innings, so the stuff is there and the results are lagging. Cristóbal Salazar, the lone bright spot, tossed six shutout innings with eight strikeouts. He starts the series opener at San Diego on Apr 11, and a good outing there would be a real step forward.

The injury list doesn't help. Roy Barker is out about 123 days, and Dorian Moore (280 days) and José Elena (out for the season) are gone from the bullpen. The depth I flagged in February is being tested before the weather has even warmed up.

An offense with a hole at shortstop

The lineup is not the problem. Mitchell Barnes has four steals and an .838 OPS, and Albert McCann has two homers and seven RBI. Doug Holt is hitting .321. Shortstop Scott Gilmo is hitting .042 with no RBI and a minus-0.4 WAR, the worst on the club. Catcher Jeff Staitie isn't far behind at .167. The Guardians were also reshuffling the roster on Apr 11: three minor-league demotions, a first baseman signed, and two players sent to Atlanta and the White Sox. GM Michael is clearly poking at the roster. My guess is that Gilmo's spot is next on the list.

What to watch

The schedule is not kind: three at San Diego (7-2, Power #2), then Nashville, then a three-game set at Washington, a division rival that took the first meeting 2-1. Then Baltimore on Apr 21. A 2-7 start isn't fatal in a 162-game season, but the Guardians need to be within shouting distance of .500 before my next column. Watch Ford's next start, Gilmo's playing time, and whether Long's strikeouts finally turn into wins. The champions have the talent. They just haven't shown it yet.