Quarter Pole Check-In: Who's for Real, Who's Running on Luck
By Dugout News Desk
Arizona and Pittsburgh shredded their preseason projections, the Mets and Nashville are stuck in the mud, and one contender's record is writing checks its run differential can't cash.
Thirty-six games into 2197, the preseason projections have had time to age. Some have aged like wine. Others have aged like milk left on the dashboard. Here's where things stand, and how much of it to believe.
The Overachievers Who Look Legit
No team has made the preseason rankings look sillier than Arizona. Picked 31st and projected for 73 wins, DanielGunn's Diamondbacks are 23-13, and their Pythagorean record (25-11) says they've actually been unlucky. A 7-2 sim, capped by George Curtis's three-hit shutout of Miami and a 15-2 demolition in which catcher Duane Patton went 5-for-5, pushed them up ten spots to No. 5 in the Power Rankings. They've done it with Howard Harrell and Fred Lowe on the shelf, too.
Pittsburgh was a coin-flip pick at No. 13 (82-80). The Pirates are 26-10, the best record in baseball, with a 24-12 Pythagorean mark to back it up. Kansas City (preseason No. 14) sits at 22-14 with an even better 23-13 run-differential record. Both look like contenders built on substance.
The Overachievers Who Should Check the Fine Print
Cleveland was projected for 76 wins and sits tied atop the Robinson at 24-12. But the Pythagorean record is 21-15, and a lot of the magic flows through Ray Melton, whose 13 saves put him on pace for 58 with star closer José Elena out for the year. Close-game wizardry tends to regress.
Montreal (21-15, Pythagorean 19-17) and the White Sox (19-17, Pythagorean 18-18, Power No. 21) are holding playoff spots on fumes. Minnesota is the real head-scratcher: 16-20 sounds bad until you see a 13-23 Pythagorean record. The Twins have been fortunate to be merely mediocre.
The Disappointments
Nashville was projected for 79 wins. The Stars are 8-28 with a 9-27 Pythagorean record, so no, this isn't bad luck. It's just bad. Ottawa (preseason 79-83, now 12-24) went 2-8 over its last 10. Vancouver, picked 16th, just went 1-8, has lost seven straight, and tumbled 13 places in the Power Rankings; Matt Richardson's 0-for-26 sim sums it up.
The Mets, picked fifth, are a .500 club at 18-18, and a 17-19 Pythagorean mark suggests that's honest. Baltimore, picked fourth, is 20-16 and in a wild card slot, but its 17-19 run-differential record says Jerm-style trouble could be lurking. Seattle (preseason No. 6, 18-18) is the opposite case: a 20-16 Pythagorean says the Mariners are better than their record, and a 5-4 sim hints at a climb.
As for Texas (10-26) and the Yankees (8-28): Hark announced the tank back in October, and heftylefty floated that his club might be the worst of all time. Mission, so far, on schedule.
The Stars
Boston was the preseason favorite and has somehow been underselling itself: 25-11, but 27-9 by Pythagorean. Armando Ríos leads all hitters with 3.1 WAR and is on pace for 144 runs, within shouting distance of the 151-run record. Tampa Bay's Joe Townsend has 71 strikeouts, pacing for 320.
On the mound, Miami's Clarence Beard (5-0, 0.81 ERA, 59 K) and the White Sox's Joe Edgar (0.87 ERA, seven straight quality starts) have been untouchable. Cal Johnston's 1.31 ERA is about the only thing going to plan in Queens. Texas slugger Todd Duncan has 14 homers, on pace for 63, a rare bright spot in a tank. And the Cubs' Ken Simmons has reached base in 25 straight games while swiping his 100th career bag.
How Much Is Real?
Bet on Boston, Tampa Bay, Pittsburgh, Arizona and Kansas City. Be skeptical of Cleveland and Baltimore. And if you're in Seattle, don't panic yet. The quarter pole is a checkpoint, not a finish line, and the next sim brings Pittsburgh at Cleveland and Tampa Bay at Arizona, which should sort out a few of these questions in a hurry.