The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Analytics column · May 11, 2198

Pythagoras Has Notes: Who's Real, Who's Lucky, and Who's Cooked

By Greg Mitchell

Boston's the real No. 1, Washington and New York are living on borrowed wins, and Minnesota is a different species of bad. The numbers have opinions.

Greg Mitchell here, with a calculator and no sense of mercy.

Boston Is Real, and the Numbers Agree

The Red Sox (23-13, GM Kyle) top the Power Rankings at 64.0, and the math backs it up: a Pythagorean record of 24-12, an 8-2 last ten, and a 12-3 beating of the Yankees this sim. Armando Ríos and Clay Jackson both rate among the AL's top hitters by WAR, and Luis Manuel Vega leads AL starters at 1.8 WAR, though his 4.05 ERA says he is more strikeouts than polish. The Resume rank is #2 behind San Diego, so the schedule is not flattering them. They open next sim in Albuquerque, then host Tampa Bay. I see no obvious cracks.

Baltimore (24-12) is real too, with a 23-13 Pythagorean mark. Adhamhnan Susanti is 7-0 with a 1.12 ERA and a 13-start unbeaten streak. San Diego's 26-10 Pythagorean says the Padres have been even better than their 24-12.

The Lucky and the Unlucky

Here is where I earn my keep. Washington (22-14, GM neurotic) has a Pythagorean record of 18-18. That is four wins of pure fortune, and they rank only 13th in Power. The Yankees (22-14, GM heftylefty) are in the same boat at 18-18 Pythagorean, a fifth-place Power drop of five spots, and the Resume #4 credit they get is mostly one-run luck. Detroit is 18-18 but should be 15-21.

Now the other side. Atlanta is 19-17 with a 22-14 Pythagorean mark, and the Braves just hung 20 on Detroit. Chicago's Cubs (19-17) project to 21-15, and they climbed nine spots. The Mets, Houston, and Seattle all sit two wins under their run differential. Buy those. Sell Washington and the Bronx.

Arizona is the sim's loudest story at 9-1 over ten and 14 spots up the rankings, but 18-18 with an 18-18 Pythagorean mark is just average with a hot week. Respect the streak, not the narrative.

The Bottom Is Its Own Category

Minnesota is 10-26 with a 1-9 last ten and a Power score of 34.1, seven points below anyone else. Even their Pythagorean record (13-23) says they are bad rather than unlucky, though they are about three wins unlucky. Kansas City went 1-8 this sim, and Miami has lost five straight. No luck rescues those.

Watch List

Tom Fitzgerald's 63 strikeouts lead the league, and Freddie Martin is on pace for 153 steals against a record of 116. Adrian Poulter's 36-game on-base streak and a 266-hit pace both bear watching, though I expect both to cool. Susanti and Eugene Tomlinson are each on pace for 32 wins, against a record of 27; pitchers do not do that, but check back in June. And see whether Washington's luck finally runs out in Baltimore this week.