The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Front Office column · May 11, 2198

Big Spenders, Cheap Winners, and a Rockies Fire Sale

By Dana Whitlock

Tampa Bay and New York pay the most and sit mid-pack, San Diego wins on $76M, and Colorado keeps dealing. Dana Whitlock asks what it all costs.

Every GM pretends payroll is a means to an end. This sim, the numbers say otherwise.

The Price of Mediocrity

The Tampa Bay Devil Rays carry the league's biggest 2198 payroll at $181.8M, and they are 17-19, ninth in the Power Rankings' bottom half at 17th. The New York Mets are right behind at $180.0M and sit 20-16. Montreal's $168.9M is the real horror story: the Expos are 12-24 and 32nd in the Power Rankings. That is nearly $169M for the privilege of being 10 games back in NL Gibson.

Tampa Bay does have a smaller 2199 commitment of $126.5M, but 11 free agents and 4 arbitration cases are coming off the books after this season. Brock has a lot of rebuilding to do, and he may be doing it with Joe Townsend, who leads all pitchers in WAR at 2.01, as his best argument for patience. The Mets lost Dalton Taylor for the year, so their rotation just got thinner, and they have 9 arbitration cases looming. Joe Spraker arrived from the Dodgers on May 11, a small patch on a big bill.

The Cheap Seats Are Winning

Now the other end. San Diego has the second-best record in baseball, 24-12, on a payroll of $76.4M. Only Detroit is lower, at $75.2M, and the Tigers are .500 with a Pythagorean mark that says they are lucky to be there. Baltimore, at 24-12, spends $145.4M, and Boston, the Power Rankings' No. 1 team, spends $162.8M with just $67.5M committed to 2199. That gives Kyle a nice runway, though 10 free agents will test it. San Diego's closer Franklin Lewis is out 93 days, and the Padres still won't pay for a replacement. Rschwep deserves credit, but the Padres also quietly sent CF Sam Chandler to Ottawa on May 11. Contenders usually do not do that unless they are confident in what they have.

Colorado Keeps Shopping

The Rockies are 14-22, and GM redwings has been the busiest seller in the league. Since April 21, Colorado has moved Pedro Gallegos and two prospects to Montreal, Nick Byrd to Albuquerque, Brooks Glan to the Mets, and Ernest Allen to Washington. Tommy Jackson went to Ottawa this sim. Then they signed reliever Keith Richardson for $2M. I'm not sure what the plan is: selling veterans and buying bullpen help at the same time is a strange mix. Maybe the plan is to become the league's most active clearinghouse. They have 6 free agents and 5 arbitration cases after the year, and with $128.0M on the books for 2198, they have paid contender prices for a last-place team.

What to Watch

Expect Montreal to be the next seller, if the Expos admit it. Watch whether Tampa Bay and the Mets trim anything before the arbitration bills arrive. And keep an eye on Ottawa: with 5 injured players and José Gonzáles out, the Mounties are collecting bodies fast. See you in a month.