Giants Slide to 17-19 as Martin Keeps Raking and the Rotation Keeps Leaking
By Grace Liu
San Francisco went 3-6 this sim, and Michael Martin is still hitting .354 while the back of the rotation sinks the team. Grace Liu on a 13-3 loss, a mystery in the box, and a month ahead.
Last column the Giants were 4-5 with a hot bat and a hot arm. Now they are 17-19, fifth in the AL Aaron, 5 games behind Milwaukee, after a 3-6 sim. They sit 29th in the Power Rankings, and the Pythagorean record (15-21) says the record isn't lying.
The Rotation Is the Problem
Gus Bush is still the best thing in the pitching file: 3-1, 2.37 ERA, 48 strikeouts in 38 innings. The odd part is that all of it has come in relief appearances. The probable-starter sheet lists him for May 12 against Tampa Bay and again on May 17 at Minnesota. If GM LighttheWick is stretching him out, I'm for it, but those 8 relief appearances are very different from a starter's workload.
The starters around him are rough. Jeff Taylor is 1-3 with a 6.75 ERA, Bill Davis is 1-5 at 5.88, and Chase Morris is 1-3 at 5.45. Davis starts May 13 and Morris May 16, and neither profile says stopper. Only Brian Gates (3-2, 3.66) looks like a rotation piece. The bullpen also has Luis García at 7.46. The May 9 game at home against the White Sox was a 13-3 win, which was fun, but one blowout doesn't fix a pitching staff.
Martin Carries, Others Have to Join
Michael Martin is hitting .354 with 7 homers and a 1.040 OPS, and his 1.3 WAR leads the club. Tom Hurley's .331 helps. António Encarnación has 9 homers and 29 RBI, but he's hitting .200, so he is a feast-or-famine lineup slot. Pablo Hinojosa is at .175 and -0.8 WAR, the worst number on the roster, and left field is a hole until someone fixes it.
The good news is that Octávio González came off the injured list on May 11. In 8 games he hit .357 with 3 homers and a 1.169 OPS. His return matters more than any trade-block note this club will write.
What the Roster Moves Say
San Francisco sent down Jorge Rosado, Héctor Gómez and Gary Stewart on May 11, and earlier released Chris Glover, David Armstrong and Archie Lane. That is housekeeping, not a rebuild or a splash. The payroll is $96.0M and the team is under .500, so I'd like a plan with a point.
What to Watch
The next stretch is Tampa Bay on the road, then Atlanta, then Minnesota. The Twins are 10-26 and the Giants should win that series. Tampa Bay's Joe Townsend (1.89 ERA) is a tough draw on May 12, so Bush will have to match him. Watch whether González keeps hitting and whether the back of the rotation turns around. By my next column we should know if this is a .500 team or a bottom-five one.