The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · May 11, 2198

Arizona's 7-Game Heater Has the Desert Humming, but Look at Shortstop

By Rosa Delgado

The Diamondbacks are 9-1 in their last 10 and out of the AL Robinson basement talk. Rosa Delgado on what's real, what's thin, and why Allen Davis is the problem.

A month ago I told you the Diamondbacks were 6-3 on thin ice. Now they're 18-18, which sounds ordinary until you notice they started the year looking at the cellar and have since won seven straight and nine of ten. This sim they went 8-1, and the Power Rankings noticed, bumping Arizona 14 spots to 15th. I like it. I also don't trust it yet.

The Heater Is Real, the Standings Are Not Yet

Here's the cold water. Arizona is 18-18 and four games back of Washington in AL Robinson. Seven wins in a row got them to .500, which tells you how deep the early hole was. The Resume rank is still 23rd, and the Pythagorean record is 18-18, so nobody is getting lucky here; they're just finally playing to their level. That level is a middle-of-the-pack club with a couple of good arms.

Those arms are Harvey Walbourne (3-2, 3.25 ERA) and Albert Sullivan (3-1, 3.43, 45 strikeouts in 42 innings). They lead the staff in WAR, and both start in Montreal this week against the 12-24 Expos, who are the softest landing spot on the schedule. Take two of three there, minimum. Anything less and I'll be writing a different column.

The Shortstop Problem

The lineup is where DanielGunn still has homework. Roberto Sánchez (.846 OPS, 7 HR) and Derek Long (.835) are doing real work, and Greg Williams is hitting .321. But Allen Davis is at .206 with a .525 OPS and minus-0.4 WAR, and the worst everyday bat on the club sits at a premium position. Rob Carter has no home runs and a .679 OPS at third. You can win a week with that, as Arizona just did. You can't win a pennant race with it.

The bullpen is the other soft spot. Alonso García has nine saves but a 5.40 ERA, and Bill Weaver's is 6.92. Javier Guerra, the waiver pickup from Ottawa, has a 6.75 ERA and just nine strikeouts in 20 innings. Gunn also did his usual roster shuffle on May 11, designating and recalling Juan Cantú, Pedro Rodríguez and Raymilson Moller. I'll say it plainly: that churn is roster housekeeping, not a plan.

What to Watch

Watch the middle infield. If Davis doesn't climb out of the .200s, Gunn needs a bat, and the trade block has been quiet from him. Watch Walbourne and Sullivan, who are both arbitration-bound after the year, so the front office has a pricing question coming. And watch the schedule: Montreal first, then St. Louis at home, then a three-game division test against first-place Washington. That series will tell us whether this is a contender or just a hot week in the desert.