The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · May 11, 2198

Guardians Climb Out of the Cellar Hole, But the Bats Still Sleep

By Nadia Kovac

Cleveland went 5-4 this sim and is 10-15 since a 2-7 start. Nadia Kovac on what has improved, what hasn't, and why the bottom of the lineup is the real problem.

When I last wrote, the World Series sweepers were 2-7. They are 12-24 now, still tied with Miami for last in AL Robinson, 10 games behind Washington. The standings say the season is slipping. The trend line says it has steadied. Cleveland has gone 10-17 since that column, went 5-4 this sim, and is 6-4 over its last ten, the only 6-4 mark among the bottom six teams in the Power Rankings. The Guardians are 31st, up four spots.

The Pitching Is Better, Not Fixed

The rotation is the reason for the lift, with a caveat. Cristóbal Salazar is 3-1 with a 3.57 ERA, Joshua Ford is 3-3 at 4.29, and Léo Charles has 44 innings at 4.50. Those are respectable numbers. Paul Long is 1-6 despite a 4.86 ERA and 40 strikeouts in 37 innings, which tells me more about run support than about Long. Bob Ward is the problem. He is 2-4 with an 8.02 ERA, and he starts Cleveland's opener at Chicago on May 11 and again at Houston on May 16. In the pen, John Boyce has 25 strikeouts in 15.2 innings at a 2.30 ERA and is the best arm on the staff by WAR. Closer Ray Melton has six saves but a negative WAR, so I would not call the ninth inning settled.

The Lineup Has Two Black Holes

The offense is where the damage is. Right fielder Doug Holt is hitting .195 with a .553 OPS, and catcher Jeff Staitie is at .172 and .509. Together they are about a full win below replacement. Meanwhile Wally Morgan is hitting .441 with a 1.045 OPS in 19 games, and Mitchell Barnes has 10 steals with a .799 OPS. First baseman Albert McCann leads the club with 8 homers and 25 RBI. Morgan's playing time is the easiest fix on the roster. GM Michael needs to decide how long a .509 OPS gets to catch. Robert Coste, signed to a $2.5M deal on May 1, is a bat to watch, though the fact sheet gives me no stats for him yet.

What to Watch

The schedule is manageable. Cleveland visits Chicago, then Houston, and the Cubs rotation has Bill Rice at a 1.67 ERA. Seattle comes to Cleveland May 17-19, and those are division games against the Mariners, who sit one game out of first. The roster is not a contender, but the Guardians have stopped sinking. Before my next column, watch whether Morgan stays in the lineup, whether Ward gets a leash, and whether they can climb out of a tie for last place. Nobody will confuse Cleveland with a playoff team in mid-May, but a team that has stopped losing is a team with options.