Dodgers Stuck in the Middle Act at 19-17, Hunting a Third Act
Los Angeles sits fifth in the division race, Wayne Cote is a one-man opening number, and the shortstop spot needs a rewrite. Vivian Stroud on a cast still searching for its plot.
Darlings, the Dodgers are the film you can't quite recommend and can't quite dismiss. They're 19-17, five games behind Baltimore in NL Clemente, and 4-5 this sim, which is the kind of mediocre that gets a script returned with notes. The Power Rankings have them 16th, down five spots, and the Pythagorean record (17-19) says the real plot is a notch worse than the box office.
The Bullpen Disaster Reel Got a Sequel
Last month I called the bullpen a disaster reel. Rights to the sequel have been acquired. Jason Robertson carries an 8.55 ERA and Barton Jacobs a 7.71, and both are in the red on WAR. Ty Jenkins is the lone bright light: 23 strikeouts in 16 innings and a 2.25 ERA. On May 11, GM Eli called up Al Pope from AAA, a pitcher he signed back on April 11. That's patching a leaking roof with a fresh coat of paint. Pope is a free agent after 2198, so this is an audition, and I'd say the tryout is long overdue. Eli, the closer's chair doesn't fill itself.
Rotation: The Real Stars
The rescue is coming from the front of the show. Wayne Cote owns a 1.98 ERA over 41 innings, and Bill Garnet leads the staff with 51.1 innings. José Ordóñez, meanwhile, was the league's second-best pitcher this sim: 12.1 scoreless innings, 12 strikeouts, one win. Rudy Barry (5.59 ERA) is the weak link, but this is a rotation that can carry a lineup. That lineup has its own problem.
The Lineup Has a Hole at Shortstop
Lawrence Anderson (.344, 7 HR, OPS .983) and Emílio Hernández (.341, OPS 1.063) are leading men. Dewey Cox has 10 homers and 9 steals. But Frank Bellshaw is hitting .200 with a .546 OPS and a minus-0.2 WAR at shortstop, and Keith Malaska at second is worse (.186, .441 OPS). Eli also cut Joe Spraker loose to the Mets on May 11 after four games, a fast hook even by this GM's standards. Casting changes are his specialty, and I suspect the next one lands at short.
What to Watch
The Dodgers open this sim at home against San Antonio, then visit Ottawa and Pittsburgh, and the Pirates are the hottest 7-3 club in the division. Then Boston on May 21. Watch whether Pope sticks, whether Bellshaw gets another reel, and whether Cote can keep his ERA under two. If those three break right, this is a contender. If not, it's a long middle act with no climax.