The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · May 11, 2198

Pirates Climb to 16-20 as Medina Bombs and Pitt4life21 Cleans House

By Annie Shaw

Pittsburgh went 7-2 this sim, Juan Medina hit three homers in one game, and the GM just reshuffled half the roster. Annie Shaw on whether the climb is real.

Last month I left the Pirates at 3-6 and 28th in the Power Rankings. Today they're 16-20, ranked 22nd, up ten spots since the last rankings, and fresh off a 7-2 sim, the best record in the NL Clemente over that stretch. They're still eight games behind Baltimore, but this club is playing like it wants a say.

Medina Does the Heavy Lifting

Juan Medina is the big bat. On May 8 at Dodger Stadium he hit three homers, scored three times and drove in four in a 4-3 win, and the dugout emptied to greet him after the last one. He's up to 11 home runs with an .956 OPS and tops the team in WAR at 1.3. Marcus Williams (.919 OPS, 6 steals) and Alfredo Vázquez (.324) give him real company. William Younger also hit 11-for-25 this sim. This is a lineup with a pulse.

The pitching is the other half of the turnaround. Bryan Reilly is 3-0 with a 1.11 ERA, and Ángel Ortíz sits at 2.72. Donovan Mohan led the league with four saves this sim and has eight on the year. Reilly's 1.1 WAR leads the staff, and I'd be happy to see him get every start he can.

Pitt4life21 Takes a Hatchet to the Roster

On May 11, GM Pitt4life21 designated Brandon Andrews for assignment, sent down Benton Russell, Wilbert Gibson, Blake Hardt, Leonard Adams and Jorge Aguirre, and called up Scott Newman, Otis Ogeda, Roosevelt Waddell, Bob Ward and Blaine Floyd. That's a lot of luggage for a team that just went 7-2. Russell's 13.50 ERA explains his exit. Third base is the real hole, though: Bruce Patterson is hitting .189 with a -0.2 WAR, and Newman is hitting .143 in center. If those two spots don't improve, the lineup stays top-heavy. I like the willingness to act, but I'd have liked a bigger answer than shuffling Triple-A arms. Tinkering isn't a plan yet.

Sam Turner (1-4, 5.75) and Leon Scott (9.82 ERA) are the soft spots in the rotation.

What to Watch

The Pirates visit Ottawa May 11-13, and Leon Scott opens against Andy Nelson, who has a 2.24 ERA. After that come the White Sox at home and a run through the Dodgers and Blue Jays. Watch whether the newcomers stick, whether third base gets fixed, and whether Reilly and Ortíz keep the rotation steady. If Pittsburgh reaches .500 by my next column, the climb is real. I'm rooting for it.