The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · May 11, 2198

Cardinals Slide to 16-20 as a 2-7 Sim Sinks St. Louis

By Walt Harmon

St. Louis went 2-7 this sim and sits 6 GB in NL Gibson. Walt Harmon on the sinking record, the catchers, the rotation, and what to watch next.

A month ago I wrote that the Cardinals were 4-5 and a game-or-three off the pace. Today they are 16-20, sixth in NL Gibson, 6 games behind Vancouver. This sim they went 2-7, the worst stretch in the division, and the Power Rankings dropped them 13 spots to 28th. Last-ten record: 2-8. That is not the Cardinal way.

The Bats Have Holes at the Bottom

The top of the order is doing its job. Denny Whittier leads the club at 1.2 WAR with an .813 OPS, and Jesse Fawbush is hitting .306 with 6 homers and 20 RBI. He is also carrying a 12-game hitting streak, one of the longer ones going in the league. John Milley has 9 homers and Ricardo López has 10, though López is hitting .186, so those are feast-or-famine swings.

The real problem is behind the plate and up the middle. Bryant Woods is hitting .151 with a .368 OPS and sits at -0.5 WAR, the worst mark among the regulars. George Morgan was hitting .130 before he went down to Triple-A on May 11, and Jorge Rivera came up in his place. Shortstop Eric Buckner is at .175 with a .578 OPS. Two lineup spots producing almost nothing will sink any club, however well the top performs. Rivera gets a real chance now, and I hope GM FBP lets him play.

The Rotation Is Not Holding Up Its End

Travis van Curen is 4-1 with a 3.53 ERA, Brad Crews has a 2.76 ERA with 34 strikeouts in 29.1 innings, and Júlio Duarte sits at 3.38. That is a decent front three. Behind them it gets ugly: Dave Foster is 0-3 with a 5.15 ERA, and Bo NDER is 2-3 with a 5.35 ERA and a -0.5 WAR. NDER is a free agent after this season, so his starts are an audition he is not winning. Reliever Eric Evans has a 6.00 ERA and -0.7 WAR, the worst on the staff. The Cardinals were outscored badly in a few of these losses, including a 14-4 rout in Seattle and a 10-0 blowout against Houston.

The Injury Ledger

The club is thin. Edwin Atkinson, the right fielder hitting .252, is out about 37 more days after going down on May 2. Adrián Piñeiro is out about 123 days, and Ju-young Yu about 33. Brad Crews is on the list as out for the season, which contradicts the starts he keeps making, so I will leave that one to the commissioner. Depth is a problem, as is the lack of a bat to replace Atkinson.

What to Watch

The Cardinals open a three-game set at home against Cincinnati on May 11, with van Curen on the mound against Chae-hyeong Park's 1.70 ERA. Then they travel to Arizona, followed by a division series at Tampa Bay on May 17. Sixth place in this division is a hole, but at 6 GB it is not yet a grave. Win that Tampa Bay series and I will believe again. Lose it, and the roster purge questions will return.