Opening Day Preview: Boston and Tampa Bay Lead, Oakland Splits the Experts
By Dugout News Desk
Our rankings say Oakland is a .500 team. The game says 99 wins. Someone is badly wrong. Favorites, sleepers, rebuilders and bold calls for 2197 inside.
The Heavyweights
The 2197 season opens with two clear favorites, and both forecasts agree. The Dugout's Preseason Prediction Rankings have the Boston Red Sox (65.4) and Tampa Bay Devil Rays (65.1) separated by a rounding error, each projected at 101-61. The game is even more bullish: 111 wins for Boston, 105 for Tampa Bay.
Boston won 109 last year and went shopping anyway, landing John Hudson (4.9 WAR) and pulling José Campos straight out of Tampa Bay's rotation. That is a neat trick: strengthen yourself and weaken your likeliest World Series opponent in one move. The cost so far is reliever Jerry Jackson, lost for the year to a torn flexor tendon. Tampa Bay ranks only 30th in net WAR added, but it still has the league's best rotation, and the game has Brant Cobb and a 2.18-ERA projection for J. Townsend to prove it. Cobb opens the year on a 13-start unbeaten run.
The Contenders
Cincinnati (projected 95-67) has the No. 2 farm system and a top-three rotation, with José Ramírez carrying his own 13-start unbeaten streak into Opening Day. Baltimore won 110 games last year yet is projected for 93; the game thinks the Dodgers will be one game behind in the Clemente. The Mets are the biggest split among the contenders: 89-73 by our numbers, 100-62 by the game's. Anthony's club has already lost Clifton Jackson for seven months, which makes his offseason trade block post about a glut of middle relievers look either prescient or ironic. He also moved SP William Banks to Detroit on Opening Day for 2B Félix Estrada and CF Bill Parks.
Where the Forecasts Collide
Oakland is the headline. We have the Athletics 15th at 81-81, dinged for a 26th-ranked rotation after losing Raúl Pérez (4.4 WAR). The game has them winning the Aaron at 99-63, ahead of Cincinnati, with a 3.47 team ERA. Arizona is nearly as stark: 31st and 73-89 here after a league-worst -12.5 net WAR, but 88-74 and in the Robinson race according to the game. Colorado (71-91 vs. 80-82) and Washington (80-82 vs. 89-73) also get far more love from the game.
It cuts the other way, too. Nashville led the league in net WAR added (+17.6) by grabbing Chase Morris, Michael Anderson and Pat House, and we project 79-83. The game sees 67-95. San Antonio drops from 82-80 to 71-91, and Houston from 88-74 to fifth place in the Gibson.
Who do we believe? On Oakland, the game. A rotation ranking is not destiny, and an 82-win team that stayed young (fourth-youngest roster) can jump. On Nashville, ourselves: three new starters do not leave you 28 games under .500.
The Sleepers
San Diego added +16.8 WAR, including Joe Ball and Clinton Mauch, after a 59-103 disaster, and owns the league's youngest roster. Miami (+8.1, headlined by George McMinn) lands at 80-82 in our rankings and 78-84 in the game's, meaning both forecasts see a real jump from last year. St. Louis, just 22nd in our rankings, gets an 89-73 nod from the game.
The Rebuild Wing
Detroit (67-95 here, 59-103 per the game) is clearly retooling, flipping five players to Albuquerque for SP José Mendoza on Opening Day. Minnesota, the Yankees, Albuquerque and Toronto, which lost 110 games a year ago, round out the bottom. The Yankees at least bring Justin Moody's four-game homer streak into April, and Toronto's Austin George carries a 13-game hitting streak.
Bold Predictions
1. Oakland wins 90 and makes our rankings look foolish by the All-Star break.
2. Jim Tumm, three shy of 300 homers, gets there before Cincinnati's first trip to Milwaukee ends on Apr 6.
3. Charles Curran collects career hit No. 1,000 in Houston's opener against Philadelphia.
4. Boston and Tampa Bay meet in the World Series, and the Campos deal gets brought up all October.
5. Nashville finishes above the Dodgers' division-rival Kansas City Royals, splitting the difference between both forecasts.
Play ball.