The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · May 11, 2198

Padres Sit 24-12 on Arms and Castellanos, but the Cracks Show

By Marco Reyes

San Diego owns the league's second-best Power Rank and a rotation full of zeros, yet a 3-6 stretch and a shaky back end have Marco Reyes wondering how deep the sunshine goes.

Last month I told you the Padres' pitching was the story and the rotation hadn't been tested. Thirty-six games in, the Padres are 24-12, tied with Baltimore for the league's best record, sitting #2 in the Power Rankings behind Boston, and five games clear of the NL Mays pack. The test is happening. The grade is mostly an A, with a couple of asterisks.

The Arms Keep Delivering

Larry Green is 6-0 with a 1.34 ERA, and he's 22 years old, which is just unfair. At 27 wins a year he's on pace to tie the single-season record, though that's a pace and not a promise. Christopher Martin is 2-1 with a 1.89 ERA and 49 strikeouts in 47.2 innings, and Sam Davis (3.30) steadies the middle. Donald Lambert has allowed a 0.51 ERA out of the pen with 25 K in 17.2 innings. I'd pay to watch that.

The asterisk is the back of the rotation. George Montgomery has 56 strikeouts but a 4.60 ERA, and Dave Bailey sits at 6.48. Bailey starts Wednesday in Philadelphia and again against Detroit next week. That's a trap and a half for a club with a lead to protect. The closer slot is also thin, with Franklin Lewis out another 93 days. Eric Moore (1.40 ERA) has held it down, but he's a free agent after the year, so keep an eye on that.

Castellanos and the Lineup

Cristián Castellanos is hitting .295 with 12 homers, 36 RBI and a 1.087 OPS, and he carries a three-game homer streak into the new sim. He leads the NL Mays in everything but modesty. After him it gets quiet. Félix Vega is at .222 with a .642 OPS, and Craig White is at .719. Bill Channing (8 HR, .846 OPS) and Randy Brown help, but this is a one-star lineup.

The front office keeps tinkering. Dean Thompson (.130, -0.1 WAR) went down to AAA on May 11, Troy Farley is already in the minors, and outfielder Sam Chandler left for Ottawa. Bill Field came off the injured list, which gives the bench some life. I don't mind the churn, but GM rschwep's patience for bad bats is clearly short, and the Padres need a second bat to emerge.

What to Watch

The three-game set in Philadelphia opens the sim, then comes a Seattle series with Green against Eugene Tomlinson (7-1) on May 15. That's a pitcher's duel for the ages. After that, Detroit visits for a division matchup. If Bailey and Montgomery hold, this club is a contender. If not, the 74-88 ghost from last year will be hovering. I'm betting on the arms.