Awards Watch: Stanley and Townsend Lead, Everyone Else Chases
Matt Stanley and Joe Townsend lead the WAR charts by a mile, while the rookie and reliever races are wide open. Greg Mitchell runs the numbers on every award in both leagues.
Eleven weeks of baseball is enough to form opinions and not enough to defend them in court. Here is the state of the awards races, by WAR, with the usual warning that the Pythagorean column is watching all of us.
American League
MVP. 1. Matt Stanley, Milwaukee (4.2 WAR); 2. Armando Ríos, Boston (2.9); 3. Clay Jackson, Boston (2.9); 4. Forest Escobedo, Cleveland (2.9); 5. Austin George, Toronto (2.4).
Stanley is the reigning MVP, and he is lapping the field. His 4.2 WAR is 1.3 clear of the next hitter, and the line backs it up: .342, 15 homers, 17 steals, a 1.063 OPS. The Brewers sit at 40-24, tied for the best record in the league. Ríos finished second to Stanley last year, and he is in the same spot now. The problem is Boston's split vote: Ríos and Jackson have identical 2.9 WAR, and they cancel each other out. Jackson has the RBI total (51) and 23 steals, and just had a week with six homers. Escobedo, at 2.9, is the sneaky one. His OPS (.930) beats Ríos's .919 in a smaller context. Stanley's 15-game cushion in WAR terms is big, but Matt Boone's finger injury hurts the Brewers' depth, not their MVP. Verdict: Stanley by a lot, with a Boston teammate as the likeliest second.
Cy Young. 1. Fred Lowe, Washington (2.7); 2. Luis Manuel Vega, Boston (2.7); 3. Will Kaufman, Milwaukee (2.5); 4. Joe Shelton, Ottawa (2.1); 5. Sam Garner, Washington (2.1).
This is a three-way tie wearing a trench coat. Lowe is 8-1 with 93 strikeouts, but his 3.50 ERA is ordinary. Vega has 95 strikeouts and a 3.86 ERA, which is the worst ERA among the top contenders, and still ties for the WAR lead. Kaufman is the ERA candidate at 2.32 over 85.1 innings, and he is the one I would pick if voters care about run prevention. Vega was second in this vote last year, and Marino of Milwaukee was third. Shelton of Ottawa deserves a mention for doing this for a 29-35 team. The Nationals have a Pythagorean record of 33-31 against an actual 38-26, so Lowe's wins may carry some luck. Lean Kaufman, but it is wide open.
Rookie of the Year. 1. Mike Curson, Seattle (2.0); 2. Jesús Amador, Chicago White Sox (1.9); 3. Rob Hayes, Chicago White Sox (1.7); 4. Bob Woodard, Toronto (1.7); 5. Denver Chapman, Cleveland (1.7).
A photo finish. Curson leads at .321 with a .844 OPS. Amador is hitting .329 with 21 steals and a better .913 OPS, and he plays on a team that needs something to cheer about. Hayes was 6-1 with a 3.56 ERA, though his rough start this sim (10 earned runs in 9.1 innings) stopped a long winning streak. Woodard's 14 homers lead the group. My pick today is Amador on quality, Curson on WAR. Check back in a month.
Reliever of the Year. 1. Everett Coleman, Boston (1.4); 2. Bill Reece, Colorado (1.4); 3. David Hughes, Cincinnati (1.3); 4. James Shirley, Seattle (1.2).
Coleman has a 0.70 ERA and 41 strikeouts in 25.2 innings, which is absurd, but he has only seven saves. Hughes is last year's winner, with 14 saves, a 1.00 ERA and a save streak of 39 that is still alive. Reece has a 1.21 ERA for a losing Rockies team. Hughes is the voter's favorite; Coleman is the numbers' favorite.
National League
MVP. 1. Ken Simmons, Chicago Cubs (3.9); 2. Cristián Castellanos, San Diego (3.8); 3. Freddie Martin, New York Mets (3.7); 4. Lawrence Anderson, Los Angeles (2.8); 5. Gary Fisher, Anaheim (2.8).
Three players are within 0.2 WAR. Simmons has a 1.101 OPS and 18 homers, and he won the Silver Slugger at third base last year. Castellanos leads the league with 53 RBI and a 22-game on-base streak, and he was last year's Rookie of the Year. Then there is Martin: 52 stolen bases in 64 team games, a pace of 132 against a record of 116. If he breaks it, writers will have a hard time looking away, though his .825 OPS says he is a different kind of player. Anderson is hitting .364. Simmons leads, but I would not bet the house.
Cy Young. 1. Joe Townsend, Tampa Bay (4.0); 2. Cal Johnston, New York Mets (2.5); 3. Donald Quintanilla, Baltimore (2.2); 4. Al Johnson, Houston (2.1); 5. Bill Garnet, Los Angeles (2.1).
This one is over unless Townsend gets hurt. He has a 1.64 ERA, 114 strikeouts, and nine straight quality starts, against a record of 17. He has won three Cy Youngs already. Adhamhnan Susanti (1.79 ERA, 8-1) is the only other arm in the neighborhood by ERA, but his 47 strikeouts say he is living on thin ice.
Rookie of the Year. 1. Craig White, San Diego (2.4); 2. Bill Channing, San Diego (2.3); 3. Roosevelt Lofthouse, Chicago Cubs (1.8); 4. Åke Jacobsen, Texas (1.5); 5. Harlan Hansen, Houston (1.5).
San Diego has the top two, which splits their vote. Channing has 14 homers and 50 RBI. White has the better WAR and average (.305). Lofthouse hit .341 with a 19-game on-base streak. Slight edge to White, but a coin flip.
Reliever of the Year. 1. Matt Madrid, Vancouver (1.3); 2. Joe Rollin, Chicago Cubs (1.2); 3. Tony Brown, New York Mets (1.2); 4. George Clark, Pittsburgh (1.1).
Brown won this last year and leads with 18 saves and a 1.30 ERA. Madrid has the WAR, with a 1.23 ERA over 51.1 innings, but no saves. Voters love saves. Brown is the pick.