The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Draft grades · Jun 11, 2198

2198 Draft Grades: White Sox and Giants Take A+, Phillies Land at D

By Wes Calder

Wes Calder grades all 36 drafts, from a pair of A+ classes down to a Philadelphia D. Who stole it, who reached, and whose clock ran out?

I have sat in a lot of minor league parks, and the draft is the closest thing this game has to a Christmas morning. Some GMs unwrap a bat that can change a lineup, and some unwrap socks. The site has graded all 36 classes on a curve, and I'm here to tell you why each one landed where it did.

The top of the board went mostly to form. Toronto took first baseman Doug Williams first overall, a 22-year-old with plus power and an elite eye. Nashville followed with shortstop David Fox, the player the GMs ranked number one on the board, and Ottawa took outfielder Steve Chapman third. Texas rounded out the top four with Brian La, a high-risk arm with real movement. The chalk held early, and the value came later.

The best steals were all in the fourth and fifth rounds. Montreal got right fielder Ramón Camacho at #130, a player the board had at #34. Kansas City's Nicholas Parsons, Detroit's Clarence Hathaway, and a pair of Cubs and Pirates picks followed the same script. The biggest reach was Cleveland's second-round selection of Jack Springfiel, a soft-tossing 22-year-old the board had around #726. Vancouver, Atlanta, San Diego and Oakland reached in round five. The auto pick, where time runs out and the computer takes the best player left, showed up all over the board. For some teams it was a gift, and for others it was a shrug.

Chicago White Sox: A+

The auto pick did the heavy lifting for vandalay. Time ran out at 1-17, and the computer grabbed first baseman Brian McNeill, a player the board had at #5. He is an Extreme-risk bat, but the ceiling is monstrous power, a patient eye, and almost no speed. Add flame-throwing Donald Ríos in round two and the eye-heavy Reynald Gérard in round three, and the White Sox pulled off the grand larceny of the draft.

San Francisco Giants: A+

LighttheWick has plenty of reasons to smile, and the Giants have been needing some. Right fielder Joe Collins went fifth, a board #10 talent with big power, a huge eye, and a Medium risk tag. Dave Fleming adds a 98-to-100 fastball in round two. Third-round Sammy Peterson sits in that velocity range too, though the board liked him far less. Still, a fifth-pick star plus round-two velocity buys a lot of credit.

Detroit Tigers: A

Greatness got a second baseman, Sean Huggins, who has plus power and a keen eye and sat at #6 on the board. Then came the value. Tom Esdale is a low-risk arm touching 99-101, and Bob Thompson, a 17-year-old with an elite eye, arrived as an auto pick and a happy accident. Fifth-rounder Clarence Hathaway, a board #62 talent, is one of the draft's steals. Extreme risk, yes, but at that price I'd buy.

Montreal Expos: A

jgwhite's draft was a case study in patience. Catcher Earl Flynn at #19 has a real power bat and a plus eye. Mark Carr, a 17-year-old catcher with big raw power, is a long-term lottery ticket. Camacho at #130 was the best steal in the draft. Two catchers in two rounds is a bold plan, and I like bold.

Minnesota Twins: A

Con landed righty Duane Garrett at #6, a balanced arm with solid stuff, movement, and control and a Medium risk tag. Shortstop António Avilés in round three has gap power and plus speed, and he looked like a bargain on the board. The late picks were a mixed bag, but the top of the class is easy to like for a club that has not had much to cheer about.

Chicago Cubs: A-

Doc Prothro took a chance on center fielder Harry Lund at #27. He is Extreme risk, but he has plus gap power, a plus eye, and real speed. Paul Pearson, a closer at #138, was one of the draft's steals, with the board having him at #52. The middle rounds were quieter, but the Cubs got value where it counted.

Anaheim Angels: A-

Sheen went with righty Enrique Ramírez at #10, an 18-year-old with a 97-to-99 fastball and a clean three-pitch mix. Closer Stan Durham in round three brings a plus slider-type stuff grade and a fastball up to 98. Third baseman Alan Carver in round six was a nice find. It wasn't a splashy class, but it was a smart one.

Pittsburgh Pirates: A-

Pitt4life21 grabbed center fielder Andre Thomas at #23, a 22-year-old with plus power, an elite eye, and good gap pop who the board had at #11. Two of the early picks came off the auto clock, and both looked fine. Daniel Lewis at #134 was one of the draft's steals. The one stumble was a pitcher in round three whom the board had way down the list.

Texas Rangers: A-

Hark went big with Brian La at #4, a 19-year-old right-hander whose movement grades out well and who sits 96 to 98. Idris bin Irfan in round three is a low-risk reliever with a mid-to-upper-90s fastball and a stuff grade that plays. It's a pitching-heavy class with real top-end quality. The depth is thin, but the first three picks are the kind scouts sleep well on.

Nashville Stars: B+

Jerm took the best player on the board in David Fox, a low-risk 22-year-old shortstop with elite power and an elite eye. Alonso Castaneda Jr. in round two is a power-hitting first baseman with Extreme risk but loud tools. Nashville had a rough June, so the Stars needed good news. The back half leaned on auto picks and the class lost a bit of shine there.

San Antonio Scorpions: B+

Jmustang drafted righty Xing-li Feng at #25, a 70 stuff grade with a 95-to-97 fastball and a few control questions. Scott Miller in round two is a 17-year-old outfielder with power and patience. Jeffrey Wheeler in round five was a nifty steal. Catcher Alain Quere is not flashy, but he's low risk and he should help.

Albuquerque Blues: B+

Heinz72 took second baseman Neil Chick at #21, an elite-speed, elite-eye table setter with gap power. Ronnie Barnett in round two offers power, speed, and gap pop, all in one Extreme-risk package. The Blues did not reach much and the board agreed with most of their calls. Solid, if unspectacular, drafting.

Miami Marlins: B+

Jo went with center fielder Alex James at #9, a 20-year-old with gap power and plus speed and a Medium risk tag. The middle rounds added a couple of toolsy shortstops with speed. Closer Dave Knell in round four is a low-risk arm the board liked. A late pick the board had near #972 is a head-scratcher, but one wobble doesn't sink a class.

New York Yankees: B+

heftylefty took righty Taylor Jones at #8, a 94-to-96 pitcher with plus movement and strong control. Third baseman Greg Miles in round two is a well-rounded bat who the board had at #29, and he was a good value. Robert Holmes in round three has elite speed and gap power. It's a sensible Yankees class and a good place to build.

Colorado Rockies: B

redwings took shortstop Martin Wilson at #11, a low-risk 21-year-old with a balanced bat, a plus eye, and solid gap pop. The board had him at #7, so it was a nice get. After that the class went quiet, with a ninth-round pitcher who graded poorly. A good first pick carried a lot of weight here.

Kansas City Royals: B

inoty got righty Dave Erickson at #26, a solid-across-the-board arm sitting 97 to 99. Shortstop Mitchell O'Neal is a 17-year-old with a balanced bat. Nicholas Parsons at #137 was a draft-wide steal. The class is steady more than splashy, and there's nothing wrong with steady.

Toronto Blue Jays: B

kjlamb has the first overall pick in the books and used it on Doug Williams, an elite-eye first baseman with plus power. Center fielder Clinton Colter in round two came off the auto clock but was a low-risk prize, with power and speed. After that, the class drifted. A first-overall pick is a good problem to have, but one great pick doesn't make a whole draft.

New York Mets: B

Anthony took righty Terry Finley at #20, who has good movement and control and sits 97 to 99. Right fielder Clint Smiley in round two is a low-risk bat with a plus eye and gap power. Edwi Barcelo in round three is a contact specialist with an elite hit tool, nearly nothing else, and a lot of risk. It's an intriguing class with real upside.

Washington Nationals: B

neurotic picked righty Turner Molyneaux at #13, a strong-control arm with plus movement, and first baseman Steve Jones in round two, who has power and patience. Both were reportedly headed to Montreal in the Byrd deal, so we'll see how much of this class Washington keeps. Scott Kirk in round three is a balanced bat. The back half had some real clunkers, and sixth-round catcher Tomás Féliz was a head-scratcher from the board's view.

Milwaukee Brewers: B

tacos took righty Victor Harmon at #29, a 22-year-old with a decent mix, and second baseman Steven Stanford at #65, a low-risk speed-first bat. Brady Moore is a young catcher with a solid hit tool. The class was neat and tidy, and tidy gets you a B when you pick last in the first round.

St. Louis Cardinals: B-

FBP got righty Bobby Washington at #15, who has plus control and movement and a mid-90s fastball. Tom Thomas in round two is a finesse lefty-type with elite control and a fastball near 90, and the board had him way down, but his projection looks good. Dale Brown has a 97-to-99 fastball with a plus stuff grade. The class has a few good moments and a few that are puzzling.

Boston Red Sox: B-

Kyle's Red Sox pick last in round one, and Ron Proctor at #36 was a good use of it. He's a control and movement pitcher with a low-90s fastball. Shortstop Bill George in round two is a contact-first bat with plus speed. Two of the late picks were auto selections, and the board had one of them at #1066. Boston's winning, so the draft is a side show. Fine by me.

Baltimore Orioles: B-

jasussman picked shortstop Bradley Bowman at #30, with plus power and a good eye, then catcher Nathaniel Bishop in round two, who has a plus eye and some pop. Victor Hardin is a safe, low-risk bat. The Orioles are rolling, so there was no pressure, and the class reflects that.

Arizona Diamondbacks: B-

DanielGunn took shortstop Jerome Jones at #21, an elite-gap, plus-speed type, though his eye is a question mark. Tynan Douglas in round two is an Extreme-risk arm with decent movement. The board had him at #247, so it's a reach. The class has a good top and some flat spots.

Vancouver Evergreens: B-

Dully took catcher Ryan O'Neal at #14, a player the board had at #8, with power, a plus eye, and good gap pop. It's Extreme risk, but the ceiling is star level. Greg Shepard in round two has gap power and speed. The fifth-round reach of David Maggert, a reliever the board had around #740, was a head-scratcher, and it cost them.

Atlanta Braves: C+

Cob took righty Harlan Blevins at #16, a nice-looking arm with plus control, but the board had him way down at #73, so it counts as a reach. Alec Burton and Jason Quintanilla in rounds two and three were both auto picks, and both are intriguing high-risk talents, one with an elite eye and the other with a stuff grade of 70. The fifth-round reach of Jake Waters hurt too.

Ottawa Mounties: C+

Roggie landed Steve Chapman at #3, a player with elite power, eye, and gap pop who graded out as a Medium risk. That's a franchise piece. But the class falls off a cliff after round three. A catcher in round nine ranked past #1,300 on the board is the sort of thing that makes a scout wince. One fine pick, then lots of noise.

Cincinnati Reds: C+

oldenslo took righty Cody Dalton at #35, a 97-to-99 arm with average secondary stuff. Left fielder Jeff Mills in round two came off the auto clock and has some patience and decent bat control. The class is deep in safe, low-risk players and short on ceiling. Safe is fine, but it doesn't win a curve.

Houston Astros: C+

Trigga had a nice first pick in right fielder Lorne Roberts, a 17-year-old with elite speed, good gap power, and a very good contact grade. Shortstop Dan Lamb is a balanced player with decent tools. After that the class got thin, with an auto-picked reliever ranked around #944 on the board. The Astros are 36-28, so it's hard to feel sorry for them.

Tampa Bay Devil Rays: C

Brock picked righty Mike Payne at #34, a three-pitch arm with a mid-90s fastball. It's a decent pick, but the board had him lower. A pair of third basemen in the supplemental and second rounds have a balanced hit tool and some upside. The class lacks a clear star, though the bats may surprise us.

Oakland Athletics: C

Lawdog took left fielder Ron Smith at #18 on the auto clock, and he's an elite-eye, elite-speed, strong-gap table setter, so the computer did fine. Righty Jerry Adams in round two sits 98 to 100 but with limited tools otherwise. After that the class drifted, and the fifth-round auto pick of David Hansen was a reach. A real top-end talent in a quiet class.

San Diego Padres: C

rschwep took righty Robert McMillan at #12, a 21-year-old with good movement and a mid-90s fastball, and left fielder Matt Gross in round two, a low-risk, balanced bat. Then came reaches, including a fifth-round shortstop the board had near #471. A tenth-round third baseman Ron Owens was a late find. It's a middling class for a good team.

Seattle Mariners: C-

ty5oke took third baseman Tom Jensen at #33, with power, gap pop, and Extreme risk. Two arms in round two and the supplemental round were safe but unspectacular. Catcher Millard Smith in round eight was an auto pick and a nice find. The class was fine at the top and uninspiring after that.

Los Angeles Dodgers: C-

Eli took righty Robbie Gray at #32, a soft-tossing 90-to-92 pitcher with a plus movement grade, and the board had him around #325. That's a big reach. Walton Smith in round two is a power bat with a good eye and some risk. Ron Hamilton is a finesse reliever, also at 88 to 90. The class shows an eye for pitchability over velocity, but it was out of line with the board.

Cleveland Guardians: C-

Michael took 17-year-old righty Daniel Alipaz at #31, a control-and-movement pitcher with a fastball in the high 80s. Then came Jack Springfiel at #67, the biggest reach of the draft, on an auto pick from the list, with a fastball in the same range and a board ranking around #726. Eric Schmitt in round three is a contact-first bat. The pick of the class was the opening one, and the rest cost them.

Philadelphia Phillies: D

Hal's draft went sideways early. Second baseman Dave Baird at #24 is a contact-and-gap bat, but the board had him around #240, which is a big reach for a first-rounder. Carlos Hernández in round two is a finesse righty with elite control and a fastball in the high 80s, ranked near #276. Christian Brown in round three is a speed-and-contact outfielder with a weak eye. The Phillies are 27-37, so they need help, and this class might not be enough to provide it.