Giants at 36-53: The Pythagorean Ghost and a Roster Gone Thin
By Grace Liu
San Francisco is 36-53 and the run differential says it is even worse. Grace Liu on a 2-5 sim, a Gus Bush who can't stop the bleeding, and what July should settle.
Since my last column the Giants have slid from 17-19 to 36-53, last in the AL Aaron, 16 games behind Milwaukee. They went 2-5 this sim, including a 9-8 win over Minnesota that was the closest thing to fun all week. They are 36th in the Power Rankings at 35.6, a good six points behind the next team down.
The number that should worry you
San Francisco's record is bad. Its Pythagorean record is 29-60, which is the record of a team getting outscored by a mile. The Giants have actually been lucky to win seven more games than the run differential says they should. For a numbers person, that is the whole story: this isn't a team on the edge of a turnaround. Nobody else in the league has a gap that wide, and the 51.6 roster rating is the lowest in the league too.
The lineup is thin. Michael Martin (.846 OPS) and António Encarnación (18 HR, .823 OPS) are the only bats carrying real weight, at 1.3 WAR each. Pablo Hinojosa sits at -1.1 WAR with a .567 OPS, and catcher Daron Johnston, called up June 1, is hitting .070 over 14 games. James Gilmore is out for the season, and I'd call it a hole in right field that was never really filled.
The arms
Brian Gates (3.56 ERA, 1.6 WAR) is the one rotation bright spot. Chase Morris is 4-9, and Gus Bush went at Toronto-level misery this sim: 9.1 innings, 11 earned runs. He is also hurt, out about 58 more days, which tells you how the staff is holding together. In the bullpen, Ryan Hicks (7.93 ERA) and Luis García (5.82 ERA, 65 innings) are the two worst WAR figures on the staff.
What to watch
The schedule is soft in a bad way: Pittsburgh at home Jul 14-16, then a Jul 17-19 series at Minnesota against the only team close to them in the standings. That Twins series is a chance to climb out of last in the division, and I'll be watching it. Jeff Taylor is 7 strikeouts from 1,500 for his career, which would be a nice moment in a rough year.
The bigger question belongs to GM LighttheWick. Jeff Taylor and Chris Underwood are free agents after the season, and with Encarnación heading to arbitration, the Giants have players other teams might want. Top prospect Mark Poholsky is the league's #1 prospect. I'd rather see a patient rebuild around him than a drift through August. A month from now, I want to see a plan, not just a record.