Guardians Sit One Game Off the Wild Card, and Their Best Bat Just Hit the Shelf
By Nadia Kovac
Cleveland is 44-45, one game from the last AL playoff spot, after losing Forest Escobedo and Bob Ward to the injured list. Nadia Kovac on a thin margin and a shorthanded lineup.
Back in May I wrote that Cleveland had climbed out of the cellar and the bats were still asleep. Two months on, the Guardians are 44-45, fourth in the AL Robinson, four games behind Washington and one game back of the last wild card, held by Arizona at 45-44. They did not collapse or surge. They hung around, and in a league this flat that counts.
The Escobedo problem
The sim ended badly. On Jul 11 Cleveland placed third baseman Forest Escobedo on the injured list, and he is not just another bat. He leads the club at 3.9 WAR with a .321 average, 14 homers and a .955 OPS in 72 games. Nobody else is close: Denver Chapman is next at 2.4 WAR, and Albert McCann has 21 homers and 63 RBI at .841.
The injury list shows him out about 31 more days, so he returns around mid-August. That takes him out of the next sim and most of the one after it. This is where my May complaint matters again. Shortstop Scott Gilmo is hitting .149 with a .443 OPS and is worth minus 0.6 WAR. Allen Thornton sits at .631 OPS. Remove the one star and the bottom of the order carries even more weight. Credit to GM Michael for calling up John Crawford, but a corner outfielder from AAA is not a replacement for a 3.9 WAR bat.
The arms are fine, and thinner
The rotation has been the quiet strength. Paul Long (3.35 ERA), Cristóbal Salazar (3.77) and Léo Charles (3.62) are all steady, and Joshua Ford is at 4.05. Bob Ward also went on the injured list Jul 11, out about 57 days. His 5.19 ERA was the weak spot, but 16 starts are not easy to replace, and Larry Moore, called up to fill in, has a 31.50 ERA in one start. He is scheduled for Jul 13 in Milwaukee. I would not bet on that one.
The bullpen got help in the form of Ned Kruz and Hank Carr, both added Jul 11. Mark Harris Jr., with a 6.44 ERA and two saves, is the type of arm that needs the competition.
What to watch
The schedule helps. After two at Milwaukee, Cleveland plays Kansas City (also 43-46) at home, then goes to Miami (37-52) on Jul 17. Those are series Cleveland has to win to stay in the race. The Guardians lost three straight to end this sim and went 2-5, and the standings are too tight for another week like that. Also keep an eye on Errol Pope, who is 11 hits from 1,500 for his career.
Next column I want to see Cleveland at or above .500 without Escobedo. If they are, the front office has a real question about whether to buy as the deadline nears. If not, it gets simpler.