Phillies Sink to 40-49 as Singleton Whiffs and Hal's Bullpen Carries a Dud Rotation
By Frank Gallo
Philly slid to 40-49, eight back in the Robinson, and Sloan Singleton went 2-for-27 with 18 strikeouts. Frank Gallo on what's broken, what still works, and what Hal does next.
Back in May I told you the Phillies had a real bullpen and a real Jesús Hernández. Both still hold up. The rest of the story has gone sideways, and I'm not happy about it.
We were 16-20 then. We're 40-49 now, 3-4 this sim, eight games behind Washington in the Robinson and five back of the last wild card. The Power Rankings have us 25th. The Pythagorean says 42-47, so we're not even unlucky. We're just not good enough.
The Singleton Problem
Sloan Singleton is the sim's coldest hitter in the league: 2-for-27 with 18 strikeouts and a .212 OPS. Eighteen! That's two-thirds of his at-bats. Yet he has 24 homers, one off the league's top five, and 61 RBI. He's also hitting .222 with 0.4 WAR, so the power is real and the bat is feast or famine. He's in arbitration after this year. Hal has to decide whether this is a slugger or a slump merchant. I say you live with the power, but the strikeout binge needs to stop.
Who's Carrying Us
Bobby Greer is the answer to "why watch?" He's hitting .330 with a .944 OPS and 3.3 WAR, easily the best bat we have. Hernández is next, with 19 homers and 58 RBI. In the pen, Lou Key owns a 2.04 ERA and 68 strikeouts in 57.1 innings, and Kenny Johns saved three more this sim to lead the league with 26. His 35 straight conversions is the second-longest save streak going. That's the good news.
The bad news is the rest. Ken Howard is our best starter at 3-8 with a 4.41 ERA, and Allen Gibbons has a 5.19 ERA and negative WAR. Center field remains a hole: Donald Taylor is hitting .176 with a .408 OPS. Jud Dundee's .197 at catcher isn't helping, and he and Billy Pope are both free agents after the year.
The Call
We're not contenders, and Hal knows it. Johns, Key and Hernández are fun, but with Hernández under team control, the smart play is to sell what doesn't fit and build around him, Greer and Ron Webb, our #68 prospect. The trade block is quiet from our side. Hal, get on it.
What to Watch
We face Detroit (41-48) at home for three starting Jul 14, then Washington Jul 17-19. Beat the Nationals and the division gap shrinks. Lose and I start talking about next year. Also: does Singleton make contact again, and does Jeff Beck, 8-7 but with a 5.59 ERA, pitch like it?