The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Jul 11, 2198

Pirates Slide to 40-49 as Injuries Hit Medina and Reilly

By Annie Shaw

Pittsburgh was 16-20 and climbing in May. Now it's 40-49 and 10 games back, with Juan Medina and Bryan Reilly both on the injured list. Annie Shaw on what's left to play for.

Back in May I asked whether the climb was real. Pittsburgh is 40-49 now, 10 games behind Baltimore in the NL Clemente and 2 games out of the last wild card. That answers it, and it isn't the answer I wanted.

The sim that stung

The Pirates went 2-5 this sim and sit 27th in the Power Rankings at 44.8. The Pythagorean record is also 40-49, so this is no hard-luck story. They are what they are: a team that lost 10-1 to Kansas City, lost 6-1 to Albuquerque, and found a way to leave one run on the board against the Royals in a 2-1 loss.

Then came Jul 11, and the bad news piled up. Juan Medina went on the injured list, and so did Bryan Reilly. Medina leads the club with 55 RBI and 17 homers, and he was already nursing a groin strain. Reilly was the rotation's steadiest arm, 4-2 with a 3.71 ERA over 85 innings. Losing both on the same day is the kind of thing that makes a GM stare at a spreadsheet. Pitt4life21 answered by recalling 1B Leonard Adams and RP Wing-tat Li from AAA and sending Roy Kline down. I admire the hustle. It's a patch, not a plan.

The bright spots

Marcus Williams is the reason to keep watching. The second baseman is hitting .310 with 18 homers and a .903 OPS, good for 3.0 WAR, the team's best. William Adams has chipped in 29 steals and 2.2 WAR, and Alfredo Vázquez is at .293. That's a real core, and all three are under control or headed to arbitration, so the front office has building blocks.

The holes are just as loud. In center field, William Younger is hitting .208 and Scott Newman .146, and together they have cost the team 1.5 WAR. The bullpen has some trouble spots too, with Joe Maxwell at a 7.59 ERA. Leon Scott's 6.65 ERA is a worry, even with Scott back on the injured list.

What to watch

The schedule is soft, which is the one bit of good luck. Atlanta visits for two on Jul 12-13, then San Francisco, the league's worst team by Power, hosts three starting Jul 14. If Pittsburgh can't win those, buyers' dreams are over. Watch whether Medina's return is quick, whether Adams can fill the first base hole, and whether Pitt4life21 sells with the deadline close. My bet: the fans deserve a team that fights, so keep fighting, but start thinking about 2199. The kids, like top prospect Andre Thomas, are worth a look.

See you in a month.