The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Jul 11, 2198

Cardinals Climb Back to 42-47, but the Cardboard Catcher Must Go

By Walt Harmon

St. Louis went 3-4 this sim, sits 13 back in NL Gibson, and just lost Jesse Fawbush again. Walt Harmon on the lineup holes, a sturdy rotation, and the decisions GM FBP faces.

Since I last wrote, the Cardinals have clawed from 16-20 to 42-47. That's a real recovery, if not a triumph. This sim they went 3-4, beat Albuquerque on Jul 5, and stayed 13 games behind Houston in NL Gibson. The Astros went 7-0, so the division is gone. The wild card is the more honest question: St. Louis is four games out of the last spot, with Tampa Bay holding it at 46-43. That's a climb, but the Cardinals would have to pass Anaheim, Kansas City and others to make it.

The Rotation Keeps Its End of the Bargain

The pitching is why this team is still within shouting distance. Travis van Curen is 5-1 with a 3.47 ERA and 98 strikeouts, and he gets the ball again Jul 19 at Montreal. Júlio Duarte owns a 2.95 ERA, the best on the staff, and Brad Crews has 85 strikeouts in 80.1 innings. Dave Foster is 1-7 despite a 4.34 ERA and 93 strikeouts, which is mostly a run support complaint. The Cardinal way is pitching, defense and fundamentals, and the first part is in order.

The Lineup Has Holes, and One Is Behind the Plate

The hitting is lopsided. Denny Whittier leads the club at 2.8 WAR with a .823 OPS, and Ricardo López has 20 homers even at .210. But catcher Bryant Woods is hitting .192 with a .461 OPS, worth minus 1.1 WAR, and center fielder Mike Taylor sits at minus 0.8. I flagged the catching in May, and it hasn't improved. Nobody should be sentimental about a .461 OPS. GM FBP, the trade market is open, and your free agents, Bo NDER and Orlando Chávez, aren't coming back to save you.

The bigger blow came Jul 11, when Jesse Fawbush went on the injured list. He was hitting .294 with 10 homers and a .828 OPS. The injury report lists him out for the season and beyond. Tom Walker's call-up from AAA that same day is a patch, not a replacement. Edwin Atkinson is back from his own injury and has hit .276 with six homers, so there is some help.

What to Watch

St. Louis is 42-47 with Power Rank 18, and this team is a .500 club at heart. The bullpen needs work too, with Eric Evans at a 5.79 ERA and Chávez at 6.51. The next three weeks decide whether FBP buys or sells. The Cardinals play at Colorado Jul 14-16, then at Montreal Jul 17-19, both winnable series. Take them, and the wild card is within reach. Drop them, and it's time to look at 2199, where the prospects, led by Bobby Washington at #72, are waiting.