The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Jul 11, 2198

Cubs Slip to 3-4, Hold the NL Mays Lead, and Keep Smiling

By Bill Hoffmann

Chicago went 3-4 this sim, yet still leads the NL Mays by two games. Bill Hoffmann on Ken Simmons, a thinning rotation, and why the smile still holds.

Nobody wrote a love song about a 3-4 week, but I'll hum one anyway. The Cubs are 52-37, still atop the NL Mays by two games over the Mets, and still fourth in the Power Rankings, one slot down from last time. Not bad for a team that a couple of months ago was just finding its footing at 19-17.

Simmons Carries the Torch

Ken Simmons is the reason this team is comfortable. The third baseman is hitting .314 with 20 homers and an OPS of 1.018, and his 4.8 WAR is second among all hitters in the league behind only Matt Stanley of Milwaukee. He also topped the NL fan vote, so expect a Cubs jersey at the All-Star festivities. Roosevelt Lofthouse (.325) and Ron Bell (18 homers, 59 RBI) lend real support. But the supporting cast is thin: Luis Miguel Mendoza sits at minus-0.3 WAR, and first baseman Daniel von Schoening went 3-for-24 with ten strikeouts this sim. He was called up on Jul 1, and that's a rough welcome. I'm patient, but the bat has to wake up.

The Rotation Gets Shuffled

The bigger worry is on the mound. Bill Rice, who has a 2.97 ERA and shares the team lead in pitcher WAR, went on the injured list Jul 11. Chuck Peterson was activated and sent to AAA on the same day, and António Garza came up from the minors. Garza starts Jul 16 at Arizona, and he's 2-1 with a 4.07 ERA, so that's a fair test. Vincent Davis (6-1, 2.53) and Gene Blanton (2.34) are the steady hands, while Perry Cutspec carries a 5.17 ERA into Nashville tomorrow. GM Doc Prothro also grabbed reliever Aaron Toson from the White Sox on Jul 11, a quiet move that tells me the pen is getting attention.

After the 4-3 loss to Tampa Bay on Jul 7, the Cubs also lost to Detroit three times over the week. Detroit is 41-48, so that stings. Still, Chicago's Pythagorean record matches its actual 52-37, which means this lead is earned and not borrowed.

What to Watch

The Cubs visit Nashville on Jul 12-13, a Stars club that has swept them in the season series so far, 2-0. Then it's Arizona, a hot team that went 6-1 this sim, followed by Detroit at Wrigley on Jul 17-19 for a little redemption. Watch whether Rice's injury is brief, whether Garza holds a rotation spot, and whether Simmons keeps carrying the lineup. I'm betting the smile survives another month.