The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Awards races · Aug 1, 2198

Awards Watch: Stanley and Simmons Lead, but the Pitchers Are Up for Grabs

By Greg Mitchell

Two third basemen own the MVP races, while the Cy Youngs are a mess of ERA vs. WAR. Greg Mitchell checks the numbers at the deadline, and some leads are luckier than they look.

The trade deadline is here, so the awards races are, too. Here are the contenders by WAR, with a note on where the record or the Pythagorean column complicates things.

American League

MVP. Matt Stanley of Milwaukee leads at 5.8 WAR, with a .311 average, 23 homers, 28 steals and a .972 OPS. He is also last year's winner, which means he is defending a trophy and posting better WAR than anyone chasing him. Behind him it gets crowded: Clay Jackson of Boston (4.3 WAR, .871 OPS, 32 steals), Forest Escobedo of Cleveland (3.9 WAR in only 72 games, .955 OPS), Armando Ríos of Boston (3.8) and Bobby Greer of Philadelphia (3.8, .326). Escobedo is the sleeper, since he has produced nearly Jackson's value in 27 fewer games. The catch is that the Brewers are 60-47 but have a Pythagorean record of 64-43, so they are underperforming their run differential and are not a lock for the postseason. Stanley should still win unless Boston's 70-37 record starts doing the voters' thinking for them. Jackson and Ríos split the Red Sox vote, which helps Stanley.

Cy Young. Luis Manuel Vega of Boston has the top WAR (4.4), with a 3.17 ERA and 141 strikeouts in 125 innings. He also threw 14.1 scoreless innings this sim. Fred Lowe of Washington is close at 4.3 WAR, but he left Jul 30 with elbow inflammation and is expected to miss about 39 days. That is a serious problem for his case, and his 3.89 ERA was not dazzling to begin with. His teammate Sam Garner (4.0 WAR, 3.19 ERA) is quietly the better Nationals candidate now. The ERA romantic's pick is Chae-hyeong Park of Cincinnati: 2.14 ERA, 9-2, seven straight quality starts, and the AL Pitcher of the Month for July. His 134.2 innings and 3.7 WAR leave him just behind Vega, but another month like July could close it. Joe Shelton of Ottawa (3.8 WAR, 2.89 ERA) is the Mounties' lone bright spot on a 43-64 team. Park is the one most likely to catch Vega.

Rookie of the Year. Jesús Amador of the White Sox leads at 2.9 WAR, hitting .311 with 36 steals and a .885 OPS. Darren Johnston of Oakland (2.7) and Denver Chapman of Cleveland (2.7) trail by a hair, and Rob Hayes of the White Sox (2.4, 9-5) is another chance for Chicago. Allen Milton of the Yankees has the flashiest counting stats, with 28 homers and 78 RBI, but his 2.0 WAR shows how much the rest of his game costs him. Last year Cleveland took this award with Albert McCann and had Escobedo second, so the Guardians know the neighborhood. Amador is the favorite, and Johnston is the best bet to catch him.

Reliever of the Year. David Hughes of Cincinnati is the pick. He has 2.4 WAR, 28 saves, 61 strikeouts in 46.2 innings and a 2.31 ERA, and he won this award last year. He also led all pitchers with six saves this sim. James Shirley of Seattle (2.2 WAR, 2.20 ERA) saw a 38-save streak end on Jul 25, which will not help his case. Bill Reece of Colorado has the best ERA of the group at 1.39 over 51.2 innings, but with only three saves, voters have traditionally treated that as a setup man's résumé. Everett Coleman of Boston (1.57 ERA, 15 saves) rounds out the field.

National League

MVP. Ken Simmons of the Cubs leads with 5.7 WAR and a .992 OPS, and Freddie Martin of the Mets is right behind at 5.4. Martin hit only five homers, but he has 73 steals in 107 team games, a pace for 111 against the record of 116. If he sets the record, that changes the conversation. Cristián Castellanos of San Diego (5.0, .922 OPS), Gary Fisher of Anaheim (4.8 WAR, .340 average) and Jon Law of Atlanta (4.1) complete the field. Fisher leads the league in batting average on a 55-52 team, and Law plays for a 50-57 team, so neither is likely to win. Simmons has the edge as the best hitter on a 63-44 first-place club. The Mets also have a Pythagorean record of 63-44, so Martin's team is probably better than its 60-47 mark. Last year's winner, William Adams of Pittsburgh, is not in the picture. His Pirates are 48-59.

Cy Young. Joe Townsend of Tampa Bay is the clear leader at 4.7 WAR, with a 2.35 ERA and 197 strikeouts, 33 more than anyone else in the league. He is a three-time winner and last year's winner, and his 12 wins are tied for the league lead. The only knock is the Devil Rays' 54-53 record. Bill Garnet of the Dodgers (4.0 WAR, 3.03 ERA) reached 100 career wins this sim and struck out 15 in a one-hit shutout. Donald Quintanilla of Baltimore (3.9) and Luke Blunsdon of Houston (3.4, 2.85 ERA) come next. Blunsdon is the one to watch: he threw 11.1 scoreless innings this sim for the top team in the league. But Townsend would need to collapse for anyone to catch him.

Rookie of the Year. It is a San Diego race. Craig White (3.6 WAR, .303, 13-game hitting streak) leads, and Bill Channing (3.4 WAR, 22 homers) is right behind. Åke Jacobsen of Texas (2.3, 23 homers) is a distant third. This is the closest race in either league, and either Padre could win it. White gets the edge for his average and his streak. Last year's winner, Castellanos, is also from San Diego, so the Padres' pipeline is paying off again.

Reliever of the Year. Vasily Khalapian of the Dodgers leads at 2.0 WAR, with 28 saves and a 1.71 ERA. George Clark of Pittsburgh (2.0 WAR, 2.76 ERA) is level on WAR but has just three saves. Patrick Allen of Houston (26 saves, 2.72 ERA) and Matt Madrid of Vancouver (2.05 ERA in 79 innings) follow. Tony Brown of the Mets, last year's winner, has a 2.62 ERA and 25 saves and is still in it, but he sits behind Khalapian on WAR. Khalapian is the pick, and Allen is the best bet to catch him on Houston's strength.