Awards Watch: Stanley Runs Away in the AL, the NL Is a Scrum
Matt Stanley is lapping the AL MVP field, Joe Townsend looks unstoppable, and one Rookie of the Year race is closer than it should be. Greg Mitchell runs the numbers.
Numbers first, adjectives later. With about 18 games left for most clubs, here is where the hardware stands by WAR, with the usual warning that voters also read standings, and the standings sometimes lie.
American League
MVP. Matt Stanley of the Milwaukee Brewers is the 2197 winner, and he is on track to repeat by a margin that borders on rude. His 8.0 WAR, .311 average, 34 homers, 36 steals and .989 OPS are the best in the league by 2.4 wins over the next hitter. The ranking: 1. Stanley (8.0), 2. Clay Jackson, Boston (5.6), 3. Armando Ríos, Boston (5.3), 4. Forest Escobedo, Cleveland (4.9, in only 97 games), 5. Kenny Archer, Washington (4.6). Who catches him? Nobody on this list. The best argument against Stanley is that Boston has the best record in baseball at 96-48 and its voters could split among Jackson, Ríos and Andrew Walker (4.4). That split is Stanley's best friend. Escobedo's .318 and .936 OPS in 97 games is the sneaky story, but he would need to finish the year hitting like a cartoon.
Cy Young. Luis Manuel Vega of Boston leads at 6.0 WAR with a 15-4 record, 190 strikeouts and a 3.02 ERA. He finished second last year to Eugene Tomlinson, and he is also riding an 11-start unbeaten run. The field: 1. Vega (6.0), 2. Sam Garner, Washington (5.2), 3. Julius Sanders, Milwaukee, Michael Ash, Washington and Joe Shelton, Ottawa (all 4.4). Garner is the real threat: 199 strikeouts, 16 straight starts without a loss, and he gets two more turns before the season ends, including Sep. 13 at Pittsburgh. Greg McCann of Ottawa has the prettiest ERA of the group (2.91) but fewer innings and less WAR. Vega is the favorite; Garner is the one to watch.
Rookie of the Year. Denver Chapman of Cleveland leads at 3.4 WAR, and I will say plainly that his .265 average and .745 OPS are not thrilling. His case is defense, 129 games and a playoff-bound team. Behind him: Darren Johnston, Oakland (2.9, 15 HR, 24 SB) and César Ramírez, Ottawa (2.9, .310, .814 OPS), then Jesús Amador, Chicago (2.6, 45 steals) and Mitchell Barnes, Cleveland (2.5). Ramírez has the best bat of the top three and has played 10 fewer games than Chapman, so he can plausibly close. Chapman also has a teammate in the race, which may split the Cleveland vote. Call it a lean Chapman, with real doubt.
Reliever of the Year. David Hughes of Cincinnati owns it: 3.9 WAR, 37 saves, 1.75 ERA, 87 strikeouts in 61.2 innings, and a 21-appearance scoreless streak that is the longest going in baseball. He won it last year too. The rest: 2. Henry Jackson, Ottawa (2.8), 3. Bill Reece, Colorado (2.6, 1.61 ERA), 4. Tyrone Coleman, Milwaukee (2.5, a league-best 42 saves) and Everett Coleman, Boston (2.5, 1.48 ERA). Tyrone Coleman has the save total voters love, and Hughes would have to cough up a few runs to give anyone a path. Not likely.
National League
MVP. Here is where it gets fun. Three players sit at 7.0 or better, and a fourth is a hair behind. The ranking: 1. Ken Simmons, Chicago (7.1, .320, 24 HR, .958 OPS), 2. Freddie Martin, New York (7.0), 3. Cristián Castellanos, San Diego (7.0), 4. Gary Fisher, Anaheim (7.0, .336, .962 OPS), 5. Jason Forrest, Houston (6.1). Simmons leads by a rounding error. Martin has 97 steals and is on pace for 109, short of the 116 record, but his .776 OPS and five homers make it a WAR-by-speed-and-glove case. Voters may prefer Fisher's bat or Forrest's place on the 89-win Astros. Simmons is my pick today, with low confidence. Adrian Poulter of Texas (.353, 1.016 OPS) has missed too many games to join the race.
Cy Young. Joe Townsend of Tampa Bay is going for his fourth, and the numbers agree: 6.6 WAR, 16 wins, 255 strikeouts and a 2.66 ERA. He is already 33 strikeouts clear of anybody else. 1. Townsend (6.6), 2. Bill Garnet, Los Angeles (5.5), 3. Donald Quintanilla, Baltimore (5.3), 4. Cal Johnston, New York (4.6), 5. Al Johnson, Houston (4.1). Garnet, who just passed 2,000 career strikeouts, is the nearest challenger, and a full win behind. Townsend should finish this off.
Rookie of the Year. Craig White of San Diego leads at 4.2 WAR with a .291 average, 20 homers and a .828 OPS. Åke Jacobsen of Texas has the louder line (34 HR, 89 RBI, 3.6 WAR) and Petro Voskuil of Anaheim (3.5) just went 11-for-30 with five homers. Chris Hamilton (3.3) of Anaheim and Bill Channing (3.2) of San Diego follow. White's lead is 0.6 wins, which is a good week for Jacobsen. If the voters like home runs, Jacobsen takes it. By WAR, it is White.
Reliever of the Year. Patrick Allen of Houston leads at 3.4 WAR, with 40 saves, a 1.88 ERA and 104 strikeouts in 67 innings. He has converted 26 straight saves, and his scoreless streak is at 18 outings. Behind him: Matt Madrid, Vancouver (2.5), Jimmy Hockridge, Vancouver and Vasily Khalapian, Los Angeles (both 2.1), and Tony Brown, New York (1.9, 35 saves, last year's winner). Madrid is the stat-head's pick of the chasers, but 0 saves hurts him with voters. Allen has a full win of cushion. Advantage Houston.