The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Analytics column · Oct 10, 2198

Pythagoras Has Notes: Washington Lucky, Milwaukee Snubbed, Boston Real

By Greg Mitchell

Washington won 94 games with an 86-win run differential, Milwaukee did the opposite, and Boston's 110 wins are the real deal. Greg Mitchell reads the Division Series by the numbers.

The Division Series opens with a few clean stories and one bracket that quietly hates me. Let's start with the clean one.

Boston Is Not a Mirage

The Red Sox won 110 games and their Pythagorean record says 109. Rare for a team to be this good and this honest. GM Kyle has the AL's best pitcher by WAR in Luis Manuel Vega (7.1 WAR, 18-4, 2.82 ERA), a 10-decision winning streak, and four of the AL's top five non-Milwaukee hitters by WAR in Clay Jackson, Joaquín Bernal, Andrew Walker and Armando Ríos. That is depth, not luck. Oakland is the opponent and took the regular-season series 3-1, which I file under trivia, not destiny. The A's are the 16th-ranked team in the Power Index and start Gerald Hunter, a 4.61 ERA, against Vega in Game 1. Take Boston, and don't be cute about it.

The Luck Ledger: Washington vs. Milwaukee

Here is where Pythagoras throws a chair. Washington went 94-68 on a run differential that says 86-76. That is eight wins of good fortune, and the Nationals' Pythagorean mark is the worst of any playoff team in the field. Milwaukee went the other way: 92-70 on a 97-65 profile. The Brewers are the better team that got the worse record, and they take the Nationals' home-field edge as a personal insult. Washington does have real weapons: Sam Garner (5.5 WAR), Fred Lowe (5.0) and Michael Ash (4.8) give GM neurotic three of the AL's top six starters by WAR, plus Kenny Archer's 38 homers. Still, I lean Milwaukee in a close series. Matt Stanley's 8.1 WAR is the AL's best by a hitter, and nobody in this bracket has a better player. GM tacos, enjoy the correction.

The NL Race for Best Player

Ken Simmons (CHC, 8.3 WAR, .326, .981 OPS) leads the league, but the Cubs are done, which makes the award case awkward. Freddie Martin (NYM, 8.1 WAR) stole 107 bases, nine shy of the 116 record, and will be the most fun man to watch in October. Gary Fisher (ANA, 7.8) hit .332, and nobody noticed because the Angels sat home. In the pitching race, Joe Townsend (TBA) led the league with 276 strikeouts and 7.0 WAR, but Vega's 7.1 edges him.

What to Watch

Watch Martin on the bases against Baltimore's staff, and whether Houston, a 4-0 winner over the Dodgers in the regular season, avoids a trap game against Bill Garnet (2.96 ERA, 257 K). Also watch the Mets' Jim Merritt, out about 22 more days with a strained lat, a real hole for New York. See you in a month.