Reds Fall to Oakland in the Wild Card, and Park's Gem Goes Unrewarded
By Ed Kessler
Cincinnati's October ended in four games against Oakland. Ed Kessler on the arms that deserved better, the bats that went quiet, and an offseason with real decisions.
Cincinnati's season ended Oct 6 at the Coliseum, a 6-3 loss that gave Oakland the Wild Card Series, 3-1. The Reds took Game 1, 12-5, then watched the Athletics outscore them 24-5 over the next three. A fine 95-67 year ended with a thud.
The arm that deserved better
Chae-hyeong Park was the best pitcher on this club: 12-4, a 2.65 ERA, 180 strikeouts in 197.1 innings, and a team-best 4.8 WAR. He took the ball in Game 3 and lost, 5-1. History buffs know the old Cincinnati creed: pitch, catch, and don't beat yourself. Park held up his end. The lineup did not hold up theirs.
David Hughes deserves a nod too: 42 saves and a 1.81 ERA with 99 strikeouts in 69.2 innings. He is on the arbitration list, and I'd say the Reds should pay him whatever the number is. GM oldenslo has a lot of ordinary arms to replace, and a closer like this is not one of them.
The lineup that went cold
Mike McConnell finished with 32 homers, 99 RBI, and a .897 OPS. William Stanley led the hitters at 4.5 WAR. Those two carried the offense for months. But the bottom of the order was thin. Ben Stevens played 130 games, hit .202, and posted -0.3 WAR, and he's a free agent. I wouldn't lose sleep over that departure. Ron Alexander's .981 OPS over 59 games is the one bright spot I'd build around, and he's under team control.
The Pythagorean record, 90-72, suggested this club was a bit lucky to win 95. Some of that came due in October.
The injury ledger
The pitching staff was held together with tape. José Ramírez is out about 222 more days, and Armando García and David Farmer each have about 259 to go. Ryan Simpson, who gave 8-7 and a 3.23 ERA, still has about 26 days left. Reliever John Underwood has about 52. Depth will matter more than any splashy move.
What to watch
The Reds have $59.4M committed to 2199, or $103.7M with arbitration estimates, so there's room to work. Watch the Hughes and Lonnie Guerra arbitration cases (Guerra went 11-3 with a 2.95 ERA). Watch whether oldenslo finds an outfielder who can hit, and whether the young names like Javier Trevino and Vince Love move up the prospect list. Meanwhile, Boston and Oakland open the Division Series Oct 10, and I'll be rooting for the Athletics, if only to make that loss feel a little better.