The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Oct 10, 2198

Brewers Survive Cleveland in Five, Now Face Washington With a Patchwork Rotation

By Gretchen Vogel

Milwaukee needed all five games to beat Cleveland, and Oct 8 saved the Brewers from a collapse. Now Washington awaits, and so do some awkward rotation questions.

Back on Jul 11 I asked who else besides Matt Stanley was hitting. In October, the Brewers answered the way they answered all year: sometimes, and in bunches. Milwaukee finished 92-70, three games behind Cincinnati in AL Aaron, then took the Wild Card Series from Cleveland 3-2. The Brewers won by 10-0, 5-2 and 10-1. They lost by 5-1 and 8-2. This team doesn't do narrow. It either buries you or gets buried.

The pythagorean keeps whispering

The record says 92 wins. The run differential says 97. That gap is the most interesting number on the roster. It means Milwaukee has been better than its results, and the Wild Card Series looked the same way: blowouts in the wins, and no one-run squeakers to show for it. Good for the bats, a little unlucky in the bullpen. Closer Tyrone Coleman saved 45 games with a 2.90 ERA, but behind him, Emílio Chávez (5.25 ERA) and Stu Battle (5.68 ERA in a small sample) are the weak spots. Skipper-level advice, free of charge: keep the lead small and Coleman's arm fresh.

Washington and the arithmetic of arms

The Division Series opens against the Nationals, who went 94-68 and swept Seattle. Washington took the regular season series 3-1, which I will mention once and then stop mentioning. Will Kaufman (3.40 ERA, 190 K) gets the Game 1 ball against Keith Harris. Then comes Brody Garrett, who has only 11 starts and a 3.65 ERA, against Sam Garner (3.56, 214 K). That's a rookie-flavored Game 2. Julius Sanders (14-9, 204.1 IP) and Harvey Lowry follow, with Claudio Berrios in Game 5. Brody Marino is out for 242 more days and Nick Wade is out too, so GM tacos is working with the arms he has. I'd call it a rotation held together by optimism. Optimism is, admittedly, a brewer's daughter's favorite ingredient.

The bats, and a farewell

Stanley (8.1 WAR, .306, 34 HR, 44 SB) is third in the league in hitter WAR and carries the lineup. Beyond him, Matt Richardson (3.8 WAR) has been a solid pickup since arriving from Albuquerque Aug 1. Kenny Collins is a free agent after the season and hit .294 with 83 RBI, a fine send-off if it's one. Yoshida Ikeda retired Oct 10, ending a nine-game cameo that included a seven-RBI run and an .827 OPS. Not a bad way to go out.

What to watch

Before my next column: whether Garrett can steal a Game 2, whether the bullpen's back end holds, and whether the Brewers' feast-or-famine offense picks feast. Win this series and Milwaukee is a round from the pennant. Lose it and the offseason arithmetic begins early, with eight free agents and a long to-do list.