The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Oct 10, 2198

Athletics Stun Cincinnati, Now Face a 110-Win Red Sox Buzzsaw

By Felix Ortega

Oakland knocked off the Reds in four and now draws Boston, a 110-win juggernaut the A's beat 3 of 4 this year. Felix Ortega on why the Lawdog crew has a puncher's chance.

Back on Jul 11, I told you Oakland needed a bullpen bargain. Three months later, the Athletics are a Division Series team, and the bullpen is part of the reason. Lawdog's club finished 85-77, took the wild card slot, and dispatched the Cincinnati Reds 3-1, closing with a 6-3 win at the Coliseum on Oct 6.

The Bargain Bin Delivers

Oakland's best story isn't a star, it's a bargain. Closer Tom Kelley posted a 2.45 ERA over 84.1 innings with 94 strikeouts and a 4-0 record, and he got the save in the clincher. That's value you can't buy at market price, and he heads to arbitration this winter. Dan Robinson, who earned the win in Game 4, is a free agent after the season, and so is Shigekazu Otani. Otani is the other story: the left fielder hit .538 with 7 RBI to win series MVP, after a regular season of 3.7 WAR and 24 homers. He is exactly the sort of undervalued veteran I love, and he's about to get expensive. Lawdog, start the paperwork now.

Boston Is the Test

Now comes the Red Sox, 110-52 and the number one team in the Power Rankings. Oakland sits 16th at 51.0. Nobody is picking the A's, and I won't pretend otherwise. But Oakland won three of the four regular-season meetings, and that's not nothing. Luis Manuel Vega starts Game 1 for Boston (18-4, 2.82 ERA) against Gerald Hunter (12-14, 4.61). That's a mismatch on paper. The best thing Oakland has going is a rotation with five starters between a 3.96 and 4.61 ERA: no ace, but no hole either. Clarence Gordon, the team's WAR leader among pitchers at 3.2, gets the ball in Game 3.

The lineup needs Randy Mack (3.8 WAR, .839 OPS) and Otani to keep going, with Pagán's 32 homers a bonus. The health report is a problem: Javier Pagán is listed out about 14 more days, which stings. Oakland also sent Paul Cornely down to AAA on Oct 10, a curious move for a team that just won a round. Four unnamed players retired the same day, so the organization is clearly cleaning house.

What to Watch

Can Oakland steal Game 1 or 2 in Boston before the series moves to the Coliseum on Oct 13? Does Pagán's status change the infield? And then comes the offseason, with Otani, Robinson, and Paco Rodríguez all heading to free agency, and eight arbitration cases. By my next column, we'll know if this run ended in Boston or kept going.