The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Midseason report · Jul 1, 2197

Midseason Report: Boston and Tampa Bay Rule, Cleveland Crashes the Party

By Dugout News Desk

Two juggernauts, one Guardians team nobody saw coming, and a pair of preseason darlings stuck at 40-42. Your midseason report and first-half awards are here.

The Chalk Held at the Top

Every projection system has a few wins to brag about, and the top of the Dugout's preseason rankings is its best one. Boston (preseason #1, projected 101-61) sits at 56-26, owns the best record in baseball and leads the Ruth by a ridiculous 13 games. Tampa Bay (preseason #2) is 55-27 and nine clear in the Gibson. Cincinnati (preseason #3) is 52-30 and five up on Milwaukee in the Aaron. The Power Rankings top three match the preseason top three exactly. Sometimes the boring answer is the right one.

The game's own projections were less lucky. They had Oakland winning the Aaron at 99-63. The Athletics are 38-44 and 14 back. They also picked the Mets for 100 wins atop the Mays, and the Mets are 40-42.

Biggest Surprises

Cleveland is the story of the half. The Dugout slotted Michael's Guardians 26th, and the game picked them fourth in the Robinson at 78-84. Instead they are 49-33, four games up, winners of four straight and up to #6 in the Power Rankings. Rookie Joshua Ford is a big reason why: 9-0, 14 starts without a loss and the AL's June Rookie of the Month.

Kansas City (preseason #14; the game had them at 73-89) is tied atop the Clemente at 45-37. Arizona, ranked 31st, is 44-38 and holding a wild card. Philadelphia, ranked 28th, is 45-37. Albuquerque, projected for 72 wins by the Dugout and 66 by the game, is a .500 team that just went 7-2. Houston and Montreal, both picked to finish in the bottom half of the Gibson, hold NL wild cards.

Biggest Disappointments

Baltimore was preseason #4 and the game's Clemente favorite. The Orioles are 40-42, 2-8 in their last 10, and have slid to #24 in the Power Rankings. The Mets (preseason #5) are also 40-42 despite Cal Johnston pitching like an ace. Anaheim (preseason #11) sits at 38-44 after a 2-8 stretch. Nashville and Ottawa, both pegged near 79 wins, are among the league's worst. Ottawa is tied with the Yankees at 28-54 for the bottom of the Ruth.

The Races

The AL wild card is pure chaos. Milwaukee holds the top spot at 47-35, but Seattle, Washington and San Antonio are all 43-39 for the last seat, with the White Sox one back. Washington has the momentum, winning seven of nine this sim.

The NL is even tighter. Kansas City, the Dodgers and Pittsburgh are deadlocked at 45-37 in the Clemente, with the two losers currently holding wild cards. The Dodgers went 8-1 this sim, jumped 10 spots to #4 in the Power Rankings, and Eli also sent six players to Ottawa for Buck Kaiser in a trade that announced the Dodgers are buying. Atlanta leads the Mays by just two over a Cubs team that is 8-2 in its last 10. St. Louis, two back, is the first team on the outside.

First-Half Awards

AL MVP: Armando Ríos, Boston. He edges Seattle's Dennis Mitchell by a few thousandths of a WAR point, and the best team in baseball breaks the tie.
NL MVP: Ken Simmons, Chicago Cubs, at 4.4 WAR, tops among NL hitters.
AL Cy Young: Brody Marino, Milwaukee. He has 3.5 WAR, a 10-1 record and 141 strikeouts.
NL Cy Young: Joe Townsend, Tampa Bay, and it isn't close. His 5.0 WAR leads all of baseball, along with a 1.75 ERA, 163 strikeouts and 10 straight quality starts.
Rookies: Joshua Ford in the AL, and Houston's Marc Mitchell, the NL's June Rookie of the Month, in the NL.

What to Expect

Townsend is on pace for 322 strikeouts, 18 shy of David Taylor's 2028 record. Washington's Tony Quintero is on pace for 107 steals, chasing Arthur Washington's 116. Both look like real threats to the record book. Houston's pitching depth takes a hit with Tom Mitchell likely gone for the year, and the Astros have lost four straight.

Right after the All-Star break, the heavyweights collide. Cincinnati visits Tampa Bay, with Townsend lined up, then visits Milwaukee before hosting Boston. Expect the AL wild card to stay a five-team scrum into August, and expect at least one of the three Clemente co-leaders to fade. Our money says the Dodgers don't.