Giants Finish 65-97 With a Pythagorean Hangover and a Winter Full of Homework
By Grace Liu
San Francisco ended 65-97 and tied for last in the AL Aaron, with a run differential that says it was worse. Grace Liu on Chase Morris, the bullpen wreckage, and a long offseason to-do list.
The Giants closed the books at 65-97, tied with Minnesota for last in the AL Aaron and 30 games behind Cincinnati. Since my July column, when San Francisco stood 36-53, the club went 29-44. The Pythagorean ghost I flagged has fully materialized: the run differential says 58-104, a gap of seven wins. GM LighttheWick can call the record a little unlucky if he wants, but the underlying math is the real story. The Giants finished 35th in the Power Rankings, ahead of only Nashville.
The one bright spot, and one bright prospect
Chase Morris is the reason the rotation wasn't a total write-off. He led the staff with 3.7 WAR, 171 strikeouts in 176.1 innings and a 3.88 ERA. His 9-14 record is a run-support story, not a quality story. If you want a numbers-nerd rule of thumb: when your ace's ERA is better than your team's results suggest, the offense and bullpen are the problem. Brian Gates (8-14, 4.52) is a perfectly fine back-end arm, and Gus Bush (3.89 ERA, 123 K in 108.2 innings) was better than his 4-8 record when healthy.
On offense, António Encarnación (.256, 29 HR, 93 RBI, .813 OPS, 2.3 WAR) carried the load, with Michael Martin (24 HR) and Octávio González (26 HR in 114 games) behind him. The Giants also hold the league's No. 1 prospect in LF Mark Poholsky, age 22, with a medium risk grade. That is the best news in the organization, and I'd argue the club should clear a path for him.
The bullpen and the center field problem
Here's where it fell apart. Luis García (-2.2 WAR, 4.97 ERA over 116 innings) and Ryan Hicks (-1.7 WAR, 6.88 ERA) were the two worst pitchers on the staff by WAR, and the team threw García out there 71 times. Anthony Garrett posted -0.8 WAR in center despite 19 steals, and his .619 OPS is hard to justify. Both García and Hicks are under team control, while Garrett heads to arbitration. That is a real decision for the front office: pay him, or find a better glove and bat.
Free agency also takes Chris Underwood and Jeff Taylor, though Underwood sits two homers shy of 100 for his career, so he'll finish that milestone elsewhere. Money is not the issue: only $53.1M is committed to 2199, or about $91.3M with arbitration estimates, against a $98.1M payroll this year. There is room to spend.
What to watch
By my next column, the Giants will be watching the playoffs like the rest of us, so the questions are offseason ones: Does LighttheWick tender Garrett? Who replaces the García and Hicks innings? And does Poholsky get a real shot at the lineup? Also keep an eye on how Tim Woodward, shelved since Sep 21, comes back from the season-ending ligament injury.