The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Oct 10, 2198

Arizona Collapses to 76-86 and Now Faces a Pitching Winter

By Rosa Delgado

The July wild-card dream died at 76-86, a dozen arms are hurt, and GM DanielGunn has an arbitration pile to sort out. Rosa Delgado on where the Diamondbacks go from here.

I told you in July that Arizona was back in the hunt at 45-44. Let me be blunt about what came next: the hunt ended. The Diamondbacks finished 76-86, 18 games behind Washington in AL Robinson, and they limped out with a 2-8 last 10, the worst stretch in the league. They sit 27th in the Power Rankings, ahead of only Chicago's South Siders, Albuquerque and a handful of the true basement dwellers. Nobody is going to be sentimental about that, and neither am I.

The arms ran out

The rotation I praised in July held up better than anything else. Albert Sullivan led the club at 4.5 WAR, going 13-10 with 197 strikeouts. George Curtis threw 191 innings with 191 K. Harvey Walbourne ate 188 innings. Fine. But after those three, it got ugly. Javier Guerra made 25 starts at a 6.29 ERA, and Roy Vicioso0 posted a 7.19. When your depth starters carry ERAs like that, you are not winning a division.

It gets worse, because the injury list is a graveyard. Jake Warner, who had a 2.72 ERA, is out about 346 more days with a torn rotator cuff. Dawson Dewitt, the closer, is out about 345. Cipriano Márquez, José Campos and Howard Harrell are all out too, and Campos and Harrell are free agents after the year. That is six pitchers out for months. Warner and Dewitt are both arbitration cases, so DanielGunn has to decide what to pay for arms that won't throw a pitch in 2199 for a good while.

The bats were fine. The lineup was not

Oscar Robinson (4.2 WAR) and Steve Martínez (.302, 4.0 WAR) were real producers, and Roberto Sánchez hit .313 with an .860 OPS. Robinson went on the injured list Oct 2 and is out about 26 more days, so he is on the shelf now. Then there is right field. Charles Lee played 151 games and posted a staggering minus-1.7 WAR with a .700 OPS. That is the single worst full-time season on this roster, and someone has to explain why he kept running out there. Mr. Gunn, this one is on you.

The money picture

There is a lot of room. Only $63.6M is committed for 2199, and that rises to $122.0M once arbitration estimates are added. Martínez, Sánchez, Sullivan and Rob Carter are all in that pile, and those are the guys worth keeping. Prospect Kevin Fisher, ranked 36th in the league, is a low-risk bat to watch.

What to watch

Before my next column, watch the arbitration decisions on Martínez, Sánchez and Sullivan. Watch whether Gunn goes shopping for innings, because he needs them. And watch how Robinson's recovery goes. Arizona isn't dead. It's just tired, banged up and out of October.