Cleveland's Season Ends in Five, and the Offseason Math Gets Interesting
By Nadia Kovac
The Guardians fell to Milwaukee in a five-game Wild Card Series after a 44-45 summer wobble. Nadia Kovac on what Paul Long's contract means for Michael's winter.
Cleveland did what I asked in July: it stayed in the race. The Guardians finished 86-76, tied with Seattle for second in AL Robinson, and earned a Wild Card date with Milwaukee. That is a long way from 44-45 and one game out.
Then the Brewers took it, 3-2. Cleveland won Game 2 behind Léo Charles and Game 4 behind Joshua Ford, 8-2. Milwaukee closed it Oct 8 with a 10-1 win in which Claudio Berrios beat Roy Barker. The bookends hurt: Milwaukee won Game 1 by 10-0 and Game 5 by 10-1. Cleveland's run differential was better than its record (Pythagorean 89-73), so this was a good team that got blown out twice at the worst time.
The Paul Long question
The biggest story of the winter is already on the board. Paul Long was the staff's best pitcher: 3.9 WAR, a 2.91 ERA, 191 strikeouts in 191.2 innings. He is a free agent. He also suffered a setback in his recovery from a strained abdominal muscle on Oct 4, and the club rescinded its optimistic timeline. So Cleveland must decide whether to pay for an ace whose health is a question mark. With $42.3M committed to 2199 and $125.8M spent this year, GM Michael has room. My view: re-sign him, but price the setback in. Without Long, the rotation is a decent group with nobody at the top. Salazar, Charles and Ford were all between a 3.74 and 3.87 ERA. Also expiring: Roy Barker and Errol Pope.
The lineup's two ends
Forest Escobedo hit .310 with an .910 OPS and 5.3 WAR in only 114 games. He is the best bat on the roster. Albert McCann supplied 34 homers and 115 RBI. But shortstop is a hole. Scott Gilmo hit .179 (-0.4 WAR) in 146 games, and Allen Thornton hit .213 at third base when Escobedo was out. Thornton is arbitration-eligible, so that is a real decision. Fixing short is the cheapest big upgrade available.
Prospect Bryce Neal, ranked 19th in the league, is the name to track in left field.
What to watch
Before my next column, watch the first signs of Long's free agency. Also watch whether Michael tenders Thornton in arbitration. And watch whether Gilmo's spot is open on the roster. Milwaukee's Division Series against Washington, which opens Oct 10, will show what Cleveland just lost to.