The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Oct 10, 2198

Phillies Miss October at 75-87, but Singleton's 47 Homers Redeem Summer

By Frank Gallo

Philly went 35-38 after our last chat, finished 75-87, and watched October from the couch. Frank Gallo on Singleton's big finish, a rotation that needs a rebuild, and Hal's offseason.

Let's start with the number that matters: 75-87, nineteen games back in the Robinson. The Phillies were 40-49 when I last yelled at you, and they went 35-38 the rest of the way. That's not a collapse. It's a team that stopped sinking and never started swimming. Washington, 94-68, and Cleveland and Seattle, both 86-76, played the October games. We watched.

Sloan Singleton Fixed Himself

Remember the 2-for-27, 18-strikeout disaster? Forget it. Singleton finished with 47 homers, second in the league behind Colorado's Ricardo Pereira at 53, and 122 RBI, tied for the league lead with Chicago's Nathan McDaniel. He hit just .240, and his WAR is only 1.9, so don't hand him a parade key yet. But a slugger who survives that slump and still lands there has my respect. He's headed to arbitration, and Hal should pay him and move on.

Jesús Hernández (35 HR, 100 RBI, .908 OPS) and Bobby Greer (.309, 4.1 WAR, team best) are the other reasons the lineup was fun. Billy Pope stole 43 bases but hits for no power, and he's a free agent. Bobby McNeill, meanwhile, played 161 games at -1.4 WAR. Somebody is going to have to sit him down gently.

The Rotation Is the Problem. Still.

Only Ken Howard (3.4 WAR) and Jeff Beck (2.4) came out ahead, and Howard went 6-12 with a 4.55 ERA. Ángel Flores, who is a free agent, posted a 5.67 ERA. Allen Gibbons went 2-10 with a 5.72. The bullpen kept saving them: Kenny Johns converted 46 saves with a 2.69 ERA, and Lou Key struck out 136 in 100.2 innings. But you can't ask relievers to cover 180 innings per starter forever.

The good news is the finish. Philly was 9-1 over its last ten, the best run in the league, and moved up a spot in the Power Rankings to 19th. That's a nice bow on a so-so year. Don't buy it as a trend.

What to Watch

The payroll is $117.8M, with only $39.6M committed to 2199, which means Hal has real room to work. Watch the free-agent decisions on Flores and Pope, and the arbitration fights over Singleton, Hernández and Scott Aherne. Pedro Gonsáles is a close-ready closer prospect, and Ron Webb, the #64 prospect in the league, is the arm to keep an eye on. My ask for Hal is simple: buy a starter. Buy two. Then we talk about October next year.