The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Oct 10, 2198

Blue Jays Finish 82-80 and Miss October, and the Pitching Is Why

By Owen Clarke

Toronto climbed to 48-41 in July, then ended 82-80 and watched the playoffs from home. Owen Clarke on the rotation, the expiring deals, and what kjlamb must fix.

The Toronto Blue Jays went 34-39 after my last column and finished 82-80, two games short of the .500-plus finish a playoff push needed. They landed 28 games behind Boston in AL Ruth and 21st in the final Power Rankings. The Pythagorean record, 79-83, says the finish was about right. The wild-card spot I wrote about in July was a loan, and the Red Sox came to collect.

The pitching never got fixed

I said the staff was thin. It stayed thin. Daniel Baker led the pitchers in WAR at 3.6 and still went 10-12 with a 5.08 ERA, which tells you how the rest went. Jim Lawson posted a 5.36 ERA over 24 starts. Kevin Cunningham finished at 6.06 over 54 appearances, and Stan BAsn at 5.00 over 86.1 innings. The two of them were worth a combined minus 1.4 WAR. Chris Alley (13-9, 4.28) and Nolan Bishop (2.69 ERA out of the pen) held up their ends, and not many others did.

The bats got the credit they deserved. Austin George hit .307 with a .830 OPS and 3.6 WAR. Paul Smith, Erik von Rautenberg and Bob Woodard each gave real production, and Woodard hit 30 home runs. That is a lineup worth building around, and it was wasted on a staff that gave runs back.

The winter ledger

The free-agent list reads like a referendum: George McMinn, Jim Lawson, Kevin Cunningham, Clinton Mauch, José Cintrón and Kojuro Baba all come off the books. McMinn is the one worth keeping, with 24 homers, 21 steals and 2.4 WAR. Lawson and Cunningham are not. Re-signing either at a price their ERAs don't support would be exactly the kind of contract I keep warning about. Only $55.5M is committed to 2199, or $84.1M with the minimum and arbitration estimates, against a $110.6M payroll this year. That leaves room, and no excuse.

The arbitration class is awkward too. Wilton Gonzáles hit .294 and deserves a look. Jeff King hit .121 in 54 games, and I'd think hard before paying him a raise. Four players retired on Oct 10, but none of them was a lineup regular.

What to watch

The farm offers some hope. Mario Cruz (18, #38 in the league) and Doug Williams (22, #39) both carry high risk, while Clinton Colter (#59) and Daniel Martin (#93) are safer bets. Before my next column, watch whether kjlamb spends on arms or just on bats, and whether he lets the weak relievers walk. A rotation with a number-one starter would help more than anything else. Kade Byler, 1-1 over five starts, is worth a look too.

For now, enjoy the playoffs from the couch. Boston, at 110-52, will be tough to bet against. Don't expect much from Toronto next year without real change.