Pirates Finish 66-96 as Pitt4life21 Cleans House and Eyes 2199
By Annie Shaw
Pittsburgh went 26-7 over the summer in name only: 66-96, a pitching staff that never got right, and a purge on Oct 10. Annie Shaw on what the offseason must fix.
The Pirates finished 66-96, 32 games behind Baltimore in NL Clemente and 34th in the final Power Rankings. Since my July column, when the club sat 40-49, they went 26-47. The climb back never came. Nobody in Pittsburgh is surprised, but nobody enjoys it either.
The arms are the problem
Here is the whole story in one line: not one Pirates starter finished with a sub-3.50 ERA. Bryan Reilly led the rotation at 3.65 and 2.2 WAR, and he made only 26 starts. Behind him, it gets ugly. Leon Scott posted a 5.73 ERA, Ángel Ortíz 5.47, Dave Fuller 5.24 with a 7-14 mark, and Sam Turner 5.00. Out of the bullpen, George Clark was a bright spot (2.76 ERA, 100 K in 88 innings), while Joe Maxwell's 7.59 ERA and Bob Ward's 5.17 gave games right back.
Raúl Rincón, a free agent after the year, is out about 352 more days after another setback in his recovery from a torn labrum. That is a long time to wait on an arm. Fuller is also heading for free agency and is two wins short of 100 for his career. I would let a 7-14 season walk, but he has earned a fair look.
The bats gave them something
It wasn't all gloom. William Adams hit .277 with 26 homers and 32 steals in 123 games, and he's up for arbitration. Marcus Williams hit .291 with 31 homers and 25 steals across 152 games, and he's under team control. Those two are a real foundation. Juan Medina's 29 homers came with a .226 average, which is the kind of lopsided line that makes a front office sigh.
The bottom of the lineup is where the damage was. Ray Porter (-0.8 WAR) and William Younger (-0.9) were both drags, and Porter went to AAA on Oct 10.
The housecleaning
On Oct 10, GM Pitt4life21 released Jason McKay, Michael Brewer, Andrew Hunt and Craig Leighton, and also sent Bill Craig down to AA. That's a tidy bit of spring cleaning before the offseason even starts. I like the message, even if releasing depth doesn't fix a 5-plus ERA rotation. The payroll helps: $85.1M is already committed to 2199, which leaves room to shop. Spend it on starters, please.
Top prospect Andre Thomas, a 22-year-old center fielder ranked 25th in the league, could be the answer in center, where Younger flopped.
What to watch
Before my next column, watch the free-agent market for arms, the arbitration decisions on Adams and Reilly, and whether Thomas gets a real shot at the outfield. Pittsburgh is built on hard work. Right now, it needs a pitcher who can do some.