Cardinals Finish 81-81: A Fair Ledger, an Open Catcher's Spot
By Walt Harmon
St. Louis went from 42-47 to a perfectly .500 finish and missed October. Walt Harmon on Bo NDER's expiring deal, the catcher problem that never got fixed, and what GM FBP does next.
The St. Louis Cardinals finished 81-81, 21 games behind Houston in NL Gibson, and the playoffs went on without them. Last time I wrote, they sat 42-47 and 13 back. They went 39-34 the rest of the way, and I'll give them credit: no one quit. A team that plays winning baseball for three months deserves a nod, even if it earns no ticket. The Pythagorean record of 79-83 says .500 was about right, maybe a shade generous.
The Catcher Never Got Fixed
I said in July that the cardboard catcher had to go. Bryant Woods finished at .199 with two home runs and a .486 OPS, worth minus-1.2 WAR over 104 games. The moves log since July 11 shows call-ups and retirements, but no catching solution. I'm not blaming GM FBP for every hole, but this one sat in plain sight all summer. Woods is under team control for 2199, so the Cardinals can fix it by choice. Mike Taylor in center (minus-0.8 WAR, .636 OPS) is the other hole. Pair those two with Denny Whittier (4.7 WAR), Jesse Fawbush (.317, 23 steals) and Edwin Atkinson, and you have a lineup with real stars and two real sinkholes. Fixing the sinkholes is cheaper than finding stars.
The Bo NDER Question
Bo NDER went 6-15 with a 6.01 ERA over 32 starts, which is the kind of workload you hate to see go to waste. His contract is up, along with Orlando Chávez's, and he sits one win shy of 150 for his career. I'd let him walk, mark the milestone as a nice footnote, and spend the money elsewhere. The rest of the rotation is respectable: Travis van Curen's 10-4 and 3.86 ERA with 178 strikeouts leads the way, and Dave Foster and Brad Crews were both solid. The bullpen is a quiet strength too. Paul Meyer saved 31 games with a 3.12 ERA, and he's arbitration-eligible along with John Milley. Pay them both.
The farm offers a little hope. Nicholas Green, a 20-year-old left fielder, is the top prospect at #99 in the league, with Richie Weilman close behind at #141. Neither will rescue a team that needs help now, but the Cardinal way has always been to build from within and fill the gaps smartly.
What to Watch
With $90.5M committed for 2199 and $120.1M once arbitration is counted, FBP has room to work against a $136.3M payroll this year. Watch whether he chases a real catcher before the winter ends, how the Meyer and Milley arbitration cases play out, and whether Green gets a long look next spring. Houston, with 102 wins, is the bar in this division. A club that finished 81-81 has plenty of ground to make up.