Tigers Finish 67-95 as Steven Stewart Shines and First Base Stays a Mess
By Elena Cruz
Detroit ended 67-95, still in the NL Mays basement. Elena Cruz on Steven Stewart's big year, the Phil George and catcher holes, and what Greatness must fix before 2199.
The Tigers closed the book on 2198 at 67-95, 24 games behind the New York Mets in NL Mays and last in the division. Back in July I wrote that Detroit was seven under and thin. They finished 28 under. I take no pleasure in being right, but I'll take the effort grade: this team kept showing up, even when the roster didn't give it much to work with.
The bright spot: Steven Stewart
If you want a reason to keep the lights on at Comerica, start with Steven Stewart. The right fielder hit .272 with 33 homers, 109 RBI, 33 steals and an .878 OPS, good for 4.1 WAR, the best on the club by a wide margin. That's a real player, the kind who gets his hands dirty every night. Mehmet Ducrocq (.293, 3.5 WAR) and Joe Horne (30 steals, 2.4 WAR) are solid helpers, and Paco Álvarez hit .295 with an .806 OPS in 105 games. He's still on a team-control deal, which is good news.
The holes are ugly, and they're where I said they were
First base was the July problem and it's still the problem. Phil George hit 30 homers but also hit .191 with a .674 OPS and finished at minus 0.8 WAR. Power that doesn't get on base isn't power, it's a pretty highlight reel. Catcher is worse: Kunimichi Yamada hit .166 with a .558 OPS, minus 1.5 WAR, the worst bat on the team by a mile. Two spots, a combined minus 2.3 WAR. Fix those and you've added a real chunk of wins without touching anything else.
The bullpen needs help, too. David Belcher (6.14 ERA) and Paul Allison (5.31) both gave up too many runs, though Allison's 93 strikeouts in 76.1 innings suggest there's something to work with. The rotation was fine and unspectacular. William Banks led it with 3.7 WAR and a 3.99 ERA, and the 5-11 record says more about the lineup behind him than about him. He's under team control for 2199, which is good.
The offseason
Greatness has real flexibility. Detroit paid $84.0M this year and has only $41.4M committed to 2199, about $83.5M once arbitration and minimums are counted. Carl Armstrong and Ed Brooks are arbitration cases to sort out. The farm offers little in the short term: Bob Thompson (#107 league-wide) is 18 and carries extreme risk, and Corey Wallace (#185) is a low-risk second baseman who could be closer than the others. The Tigers also lost the retired Jon Carey and Norm Unroe off the roster.
What to watch
Before my next column, watch how Greatness handles first base and catcher, because that's the whole ballgame. Watch whether Stewart gets a long-term partner in the lineup. Detroit has the money. Now it needs the plan.