The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Oct 10, 2198

Padres Miss the Playoffs by Two Games, and Castellanos Is Hurt

By Marco Reyes

San Diego finished 88-74 and watched October from the couch. Marco Reyes on a wasted ace-caliber bat, an arm-rich bullpen, and what GM rschwep does next.

The July slide is now a finished story. San Diego went 88-74, third in the NL Mays, three games behind the Mets and two behind the Cubs. By the final Power Rankings the Padres sat 11th, with a Pythagorean record of 90-72 that says they deserved better. That's the lingering ache of the season: two wins separated them from a division title, and in this league the title is the ticket.

The Wild Card Moment Slipped Away

It takes a little sting to say, but the Padres actually showed up in the playoff picture. Christopher Martin shut out Baltimore 7-0 on five hits on Oct 5, and the Orioles then took the Wild Card series 3-1 anyway. Those were the Padres' two wins that mattered most, and they came with a team too thin to move past that. George Montgomery's 235 strikeouts and 15 wins, plus Martin's 3.62 ERA, say the rotation did its job after a shaky summer. I'll take that as a win for the young-arm crowd, even if the standings disagree.

Castellanos Was the Season

Cristián Castellanos hit .273 with 29 homers and an .931 OPS, and his 7.3 WAR is the best on the roster by two full wins over Randy Brown at 5.2. The league's hitter WAR board puts him fifth overall. He went on the injured list Oct 2 and is out about 29 more days. That's the real cost: the best bat missed the biggest games. The bottom of the lineup is the other problem. Catcher Derrek Cayones hit .174 with a .480 OPS, and right fielder Troy Farley hit .147 in ten games. Behind the plate and in right, there's work to do, and GM rschwep knows it.

The Winter Ledger

The books are friendly. Payroll was $85.2M, with only $31.0M committed to 2199, or $80.8M with arbitration and minimum estimates. Reliever Eric Moore (2.96 ERA over 97.1 innings) is a free agent, and I'd keep him; bullpens like his don't grow on trees. Arbitration looms for Jerry Harris, Randy Brown, and Montgomery. On the farm, third baseman José Correa is the league's No. 11 prospect, and arms like Andrés Pacheco (No. 21) and Robert McMillan (No. 124) are the kind I love to dream on.

What to Watch

Before my next column: Moore's contract decision, how Castellanos's recovery is tracking, and whether rschwep shops for a real catcher. Also keep an eye on Brown's arbitration number. The window is open. It just needs a better door.