The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

League Championship Series preview · Oct 20, 2198

LCS Preview: Brewers-A's Is a Toss-Up, Orioles Own the Dodgers

By Dugout News Desk

Milwaukee and Oakland meet in a pitching-thin AL showdown, while Baltimore carries a 11-1 season-series edge into the NL. Our picks and the arms that decide them.

AL: Milwaukee Brewers vs. Oakland Athletics

Two teams that needed the Wild Card Series just to get here now play for a pennant. Milwaukee (92-70) knocked off Washington 4-1 in the Division Series. Oakland (85-77) bounced 110-win Boston 4-2, with closer Tom Kelley recording three saves and a win in the series. The Power Index rates Milwaukee fifth and Oakland 16th, and the regular season series ended 6-6, so don't expect either side to feel intimidated.

The edge is on the mound. Milwaukee's rotation is just better on paper: Will Kaufman (3.40 ERA), Claudio Berrios (3.57), Brody Garrett (3.65 in 11 starts) and Julius Sanders (3.79, 204 innings) all sit under 3.80. Oakland counters with Clarence Gordon (4.34), William Kirk (4.37), Gerald Hunter (4.61) and Bobby Sanders (3.96). That is a lot of ERAs in the mid-fours to hand to a lineup that has to keep scoring. The Brewers do have a hole at the back end, with closer Tyrone Coleman out 76 days, so Oakland's path is late-inning chaos. The Athletics also get shortstop Javier Pagán back in about four days, a nice boost for a team that has been living on grit.

Opinion: Oakland has been the better story, but the Brewers' arms are deeper, and their Pythagorean record (97-65) says they were better than 92 wins suggests. Pick: Brewers in 6.

NL: Los Angeles Dodgers vs. Baltimore Orioles

Here is the number to chew on: Baltimore went 11-1 against Los Angeles this season. Yes, 11-1. The Dodgers are the lowly 88-win side, ranked 11th in the Power Index to Baltimore's third, and they still found a way to beat Houston 4-2, riding José Ordóñez and a stingy bullpen. Baltimore needed all seven games to outlast the Mets, closing it out Oct. 18 behind Adhamhnan Susanti.

Pitching sets this up beautifully. Game 1 is Donald Quintanilla (15-7, 3.06) against Stanton Moore (7-11, 4.55), a mismatch in Baltimore's favor, and Game 2 is Albert Díaz (3.31) against Rudy Barry (4.37). L.A. gets its best starters later: Ordóñez (16-6, 3.19) in Game 3 and Bill Garnet (2.96 ERA, 257 strikeouts) in Game 4. If the Dodgers survive the first two games, that is their window. The Orioles, meanwhile, are missing first baseman Jeff McCarty, and a seven-game dogfight with New York left their rotation in a tight spot, but Don Iversen (13-5) is waiting.

Opinion: The Dodgers have the two best arms in the series, but 11-1 is 11-1. Pick: Orioles in 6.

The Bottom Line

Expect a Brewers-Orioles World Series, and we like Baltimore's depth to carry the trophy.