Hall of Fame Watch: Barrón Is a Lock, Charles Closing In
By Marcus Bell
Charles Barrón towers over the right-field standard, Léo Charles is still adding to a monster résumé, and a pack of bubble cases waits on the vote. Who's in, and who's fading?
A column on Hall of Fame cases always starts with the yardstick, so here it is. Our JAWS standard averages career WAR and best-seven-year peak for every inductee whose career played out entirely in The Dugout. It sits at 51.5 for right fielders, 55.4 for starters, 48.5 for left fielders, 57.2 for first basemen and 54.2 for second basemen. Relievers sit at 23.8. Measure the watchlist against that, and against the recent classes, and the picture gets clear fast.
The Lock
Charles Barrón is not a debate. The retired right fielder carries 119.8 career WAR, a 56.9 peak and a JAWS of 88.3, which is 171 percent of the standard at his position. He clears the bar by nearly forty points. Compare that with the 2196 class: Frawsen Kasiya went in at 57.1 and Al Johnstoune at 42.8. Barrón's number is about half again as large as Kasiya's. If the voters keep him out, they owe the rest of us an explanation. This is the kind of player the Hall was built for, and the only open question is how soon the plaque goes up.
Already Knocking: The Active Stars
Léo Charles is the best active case in the league. The Cleveland Guardians lefty sits at 97.6 WAR and a 44.6 peak, for a JAWS of 71.1, or 128 percent of the starter standard. He is 6th all-time in career wins at 256 and just 34 strikeouts short of passing Dave Greenwalt on the list at 3,055. Add a fresh World Series ring from October, and the résumé is essentially done. Everything from here is polish.
Steve Lawles, the active left fielder, stands at 116 percent of his standard with a JAWS of 56.2 against 48.5. That is a comfortable cushion, especially at a position where the last three classes (Wooten, Rivera and Johnstoune) all got in with scores between 42.8 and 43.1. Lawles is far better than any of them by the numbers. Don't let a quiet year fool you: he is on the path.
Safe, But Not Done
Kevin Nelson and Travis Stewart both rate 108 percent. Nelson, the New York Yankees first baseman, has 75.7 WAR and a 62.0 JAWS against 57.2. He is also 2 steals from 600 for his career, the sort of round number voters remember. Stewart, the Kansas City second baseman, has 65.3 WAR and a 51.9 peak, good for 58.6 against 54.2. His peak is the stronger half of his case, and he stole 60 bases this season, so the legs are still working. Both are over the line today, but a few more productive years would turn a pass into a landslide.
The Bubble
Cal Johnston of the New York Mets is right on the edge at 102 percent: 68.9 WAR, a 44.4 peak, and a 56.7 JAWS against 55.4. His 6.1 pitching WAR this season ranked fourth in the league, so he is still adding. One more strong year builds a real cushion.
The retired relievers are a tight squeeze, too. Ben Heners sits at 24.2 against 23.8, and In-chul Yu at 23.9, which is 100 percent. Those are razor-thin margins, and relievers are always a tough sell. Yu is still on the Texas injury list, 222 days out, which makes a comeback look unlikely. If the voters want a reliever, Heners has the better claim by a hair.
Brandon Ferguson, at 101 percent, is a curious one: 76.6 WAR, but only a 35.8 peak. He earned his place with longevity, not brilliance, which the voters have sometimes rewarded and sometimes not.
Fading
Javier Pérez (99 percent) and António Valenzuela (95 percent) are both retired, and neither has an active season left to add. Pérez is a single point short, which is cruel. Valenzuela's 34.4 peak is the thinnest on the list, and no amount of waiting changes it. Miguel Alvero, at 107 percent, has the opposite problem: a long career with a 42.1 peak. These are the names that make you think about what kind of player the voters want. Recent classes suggest the bar is lower than the numbers imply, since Ruíz went in at 37.0. That is the best hope for the near-misses. Retired players only get older, though, and the memory of a career fades with each ballot.