The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Feb 25, 2198

Blue Jays Open Spring With a Roster Purge and a Pitching Problem

By Owen Clarke

Toronto cut five players, promoted five more, and signed Karl Meaker for $1.3M. After 98 losses, is that a plan or just a clean desk?

The Toronto Blue Jays opened spring training the way a tired homeowner opens a closet: by throwing a lot of things out. On Feb. 25 the club released Pedro Beltrán, Gianni Schrijver, Callum Womersley, Wei-sng Zhang and Kelsey Braber, then called up Steve Muljana, Bruce Smith, Steven Nance, Quincy Coleman and Jeff Kelley. They also signed starter Karl Meaker to a one-year, $1.3 million deal. It is tidy work. Whether it is progress is another matter.

The Pitching Is the Problem

Toronto went 64-98 and sits 33rd in the Power Rankings at 39.6, ahead of only New York and Detroit and Nashville's basement. The pitching explains most of it. Francisco Barbosa led the staff with 2.6 WAR and still went 7-15 with a 4.84 ERA. Jim Lawson went 7-12, 4.37. John Davis ate 205 innings at 4.61 and lost 15 games. Behind them the bullpen leaked: Troy Anderson posted a 6.29 ERA across 13 starts, Bill Hunt checked in at 5.95 and Stan BAsn at 5.07.

Meaker at $1.3 million is a fair gamble, and a cheap one. But a gamble is not a rotation. GM xkyleactivex has about $103.4 million on the 2198 books and, by my math, not much to show for it on the mound. Lawson is a free agent after this season, so Toronto may be paying to watch him leave.

Some Bats Worth Keeping

The offense has real pieces. Catcher Paul Smith led the lineup at 3.9 WAR with 25 homers and an .810 OPS, and right fielder Cliff O'Neal added 3.5 WAR and a .807 OPS. O'Neal is under team control past this year, which is the kind of contract I like to mention. The center field spot is the soft one: Yaþar Besikci (-0.7 WAR) and Dave Whitney (-0.9) were both well below replacement level. Whoever wins that job this spring will earn it by default.

The silver lining is the draft. Toronto won the lottery and holds the first overall pick, and the farm already has Mario Cruz, a 17-year-old righty ranked 30th in the league. Cruz carries extreme risk, but a 65 future value is a lovely thing to dream on.

What to Watch

This is the last sim to sign free agents, so the front office has one more window to shore up the rotation. Watch for an arm that is better than Meaker, who is the cheapest name on the page. Watch who claims center field. And watch whether the pick at No. 1 becomes a headline or just a hope. Toronto needs a good month, because the alternative is another long summer.