The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Prospects column · Feb 25, 2198

Giants Own the Farm, and Poholsky Wears the Crown

By Wes Calder

San Francisco's farm is the deepest in the league, and its best bat sits atop our list. Wes Calder on the Giants, a cluster of risky teenagers, and who's climbing.

Spring training is under way, and I've always liked this time of year best. The grass is fresh, the radar guns are warm, and every kid in camp is still a lottery ticket. Let me tell you about three tickets worth holding.

Giants Hold the Deed

Leftfielder Mark Poholsky, 21, is still No. 1 on our list, with a score of 69.4 and a future value of 70. He's the only 70 FV on the board, and he does it with only a Medium risk tag. That's a rare mix of ceiling and floor.

He isn't alone in San Francisco. Right fielder John Watson, 20, sits at No. 14 and climbed a spot. The Giants lead all farm systems at 166.7 points, with eight prospects in the top 100. Second place, Minnesota, has 142.5. That's a canyon.

Here's the delicious part: the big club went 67-95 and ranks 32nd in the Power Rankings. GM LighttheWick has a miserable present and an enviable future. Stay patient, my friend. The bill for all this pain arrives in the form of a loaded lineup.

The Twins' Quiet Rise

Minnesota went 71-91, but catcher Danny Rankin, 20, ticked up to No. 7 with a Low risk grade. A young catcher who grades safe and carries a 65 FV is about as good as it gets. Add center fielder Alex Zaneski, 19, at No. 18, and GM Con has two top-20 bats and the second-best system in the league. Arizona (141.8), Albuquerque (140.9) and Nashville (139.0) round out the top five.

Lightning in a Bottle

Now the gamblers. Harold Smith (Tampa Bay, 19), Vince Love (Cincinnati, 18) and Román Gonzáles (Albuquerque, 17) all carry Extreme risk. Gonzáles is 17! I've seen a lot of 17-year-olds, and most are still figuring out how to do their own laundry. Yet he's No. 9 and climbing. Extreme risk means the floor is a trapdoor, but I'd rather have a ticket on the kid with a 65 ceiling than a safe 50.

The safe bets are Brian Fowler, a 23-year-old third baseman at No. 11 for San Antonio, and Montreal closer James Boardman, 22, at No. 15. Both grade Low risk. Fowler's age and grade suggest he's closest to the door.

What to Watch

Spring training is the last window to sign free agents, so watch whether any of these clubs reach for veterans or hand the kids their chance. Nearly the whole top 20 slid up a notch this time, so the order is tight and tiny changes will shuffle it. I'd keep a close eye on whether Poholsky's lead over the 67-point pack holds. See you in a month.