The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Feb 25, 2198

Brewers Have an MVP-Sized Star and a Shortstop Problem

By Gretchen Vogel

Milwaukee won 91 games and fell in the Wild Card round. Matt Stanley is a monster, the shortstop spot is a sinkhole, and spring training is the last chance to fix it.

I grew up in a brewery, so I know a good batch when I taste one and a flat one when it hits the glass. The 2197 Brewers were a little of both: 91-71, second in the AL Aaron, 10 games behind Cincinnati, and gone from the Wild Card round after losing 2-1 to Cleveland. The Guardians then won the whole thing. That stings, but it also tells you the door wasn't locked.

Matt Stanley, One-Man Brewery

The third baseman hit .308 with 33 homers, 99 RBI and 54 steals, and posted an OPS of .974. His 8.7 WAR is more than double the next Brewer, catcher Mike Floyd at 4.2. That is a gap you could park a delivery truck in. Boone (28 HR, .850 OPS) and Colin Woollams (33 HR) give him some company, and Woollams sits 6 RBI shy of 1,000 for his career, which should be done by mid-April. But a lineup shouldn't live on one man's shoulders, and I'd like to see GM tacos build more around him.

The Holes

Shortstop and center field were the leaks. Dan Vásquez hit .185 with a .535 OPS and was worth -0.6 WAR. Jim White in center managed a .591 OPS and -1.1 WAR. Zack LaLun was fine at short (2.7 WAR), but he's headed to arbitration and played only 109 games. Vásquez is a free agent after this year, so the sensible move is to let him walk and not rush him back. The Brewers did make a pile of moves on Feb 25, including signing right fielders Darryl Thomas (1 year, $2.1M) and Yoshida Ikeda, and calling up catcher Jesús Cedeño. Those are depth moves, though, not solutions. Center field is still an open question, and Shiro Watanabe's trip down to Rookie ball doesn't help.

Arms and Absences

Brody Marino went 19-4 with 251 strikeouts and a 3.32 ERA, and he's the ace. Will Kaufman backs him up well. Closer John Boyce saved 37 games but went 0-7, a record that proves saves are mostly a vibe. The worrying part is the injured list: Anthony Page is out about 92 more days and Anastasio Ibarra about 114. Ibarra was called up from Short A on Feb 25, which is a funny thing to do with a man on the shelf. I'm guessing it's a paperwork move, but I'd like an explanation.

What to Watch

Spring training is the last window to sign free agents, so look for a real center fielder or shortstop before opening day. Also watch whether Page's return date moves, and whether Marino can match last year. Cincinnati is still the team to beat, and the Brewers are ranked 7th in the Power Rankings. That's a good ranking, but not a pennant.