The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Feb 25, 2198

Phillies Wake Up in Spring: Power Bats, Shaky Arms, One Big Hole at Short

By Frank Gallo

Philadelphia went 88-75, lost in the first round, and has a shortstop hitting .072. Frank Gallo on what Hal's Phillies must fix before Opening Day.

Listen, I love this team, which is exactly why I'm allowed to yell at it. The Phillies went 88-75, finished 5.5 games behind Seattle in AL Robinson, and got bounced by Cincinnati in two straight in the Wild Card Series. Then Cleveland, the team that won our division, went and took the whole World Series. Four-zip over Houston. Don't tell me that doesn't sting.

The Shortstop Problem

Let's address the elephant wearing a glove. Leonard Scully played 27 games and hit .072 with one RBI and a .189 OPS. That's minus-1.3 WAR, and that's not a slump, that's a crime scene. So credit to GM Hal for signing Billy Pope on Jan 26 for one year and $8.1 million. Pope is a free agent after 2198, so this is a rental, but a rental beats a black hole. If Scully is still in the lineup in April, I'm bringing a megaphone to the ballpark.

The Phillies also designated outfielder Marvin Johnson for assignment today. And Bobby Greer, at minus-0.9 WAR with a .669 OPS, should be nervous about left field.

Pitching: Deep but Not Dominant

Here's my real worry. Ángel Flores led the staff at 3.9 WAR and a 3.92 ERA, and he's a free agent after this year. Ken Howard struck out 212 and Raúl Pérez struck out 212 too, but Pérez's ERA was 4.55. Nobody in this rotation is an ace. It's four or five solid arms, and in October that gets you a quick exit. That's what happened.

The bullpen is the bigger fire. Broderick Ward was terrific, with 19 saves and a 2.82 ERA, but Tom Brown (5.19) and Mark McCarty (6.65) were liabilities. Hal gave Damian Hampton $23.2 million over two years, and he'd better be an upgrade right away.

The Bats Are Fine

Sloan Singleton hit 41 homers with 109 RBI and a .867 OPS. Jesús Hernández added 33 homers, and Nathan McDaniel hit 34. That's real thump. And Mike Payne stole 51 bases, though a .650 OPS says he needs to get on base more.

What to Watch

Spring training is the last sim to sign free agents, so Hal's window is closing. Watch for another bullpen arm and a firm answer at short. Watch whether Scully gets a real shot or a quiet goodbye. And watch Ron Webb, our top prospect at No. 41 in the league, for any sign he's close. I'll be back in a month, and I want a contender, not a nice story.