Pythagoras Has Notes: Who's Real and Who's Lucky After a Wild 2197
Cleveland won the title with a Pythagorean record of 83-79, Montreal's run differential says 72 wins, and Joe Townsend may be the best pitcher the numbers have ever hurt my feelings with.
The Guardians are champions, and I have no quarrel with the trophy. I do have a quarrel with the spreadsheet. Cleveland went 92-70 on a Pythagorean record of 83-79, nine wins of good fortune, and their roster rating of 53.4 is the lowest of any top-ten team in the Power Rankings. They sit ninth, behind eight teams that did not get a parade. GM Michael can enjoy the ring. I would just advise against extrapolating it.
The Luck Ledger
The Montreal Expos are the cleanest case. They went 83-79 and were outscored like a team that went 72-90, an 11-win gap. GM jgwhite got a .512 season out of a roster that played like a bottom-five club, and they rank 22nd in Power. Albuquerque (85-77, Pythagorean 79-83) is the same story with fewer fireworks. Baltimore, at 91-71 against 87-75, also ran warm, though the Orioles were the hottest club in the league at 8-2 down the stretch and climbed three spots.
Now the other side. Boston's Pythagorean record is 109-53, three wins better than its 106-56, and the Red Sox own the top Power score at 64.7. Armando Ríos (8.0 WAR), Andrew Walker (6.2) and Clay Jackson (5.7) give them three of the AL's top five hitters, and Luis Manuel Vega leads their rotation at 6.3 WAR. They lost the Division Series anyway. That's October for you. Kansas City (92-70 Pythagorean against 89-73) and the Cubs (92-70 against 89-73) were also quietly unlucky.
The Individual Races
In the NL, Joe Townsend of Tampa Bay is not a race. He posted 10.4 WAR, a 1.95 ERA and 327 strikeouts. The next-best NL pitcher, Bill Garnet, is at 6.8, so the gap is larger than the one between Garnet and the 20th-best starter. Among hitters, Ken Simmons (7.3), Dewey Cox (7.1, with 48 homers and 40 steals) and William Adams (6.9) are bunched tightly.
In the AL, Milwaukee's Matt Stanley (8.7 WAR, 54 steals, .974 OPS) edges Ríos for the top spot. Su-min Kim hit 38 homers with a 1.006 OPS but trails on WAR, with no steals to help. If you want a pitcher's case, Eugene Tomlinson's 2.36 ERA is the best of the AL's top starters, and Seattle's rotation deserves more credit than it gets.
What to Watch
Spring training is the last chance to sign free agents, so I'll be watching whether the unlucky teams (Boston, Kansas City, the Cubs) simply hold steady while Cleveland, Montreal and Albuquerque make real additions. Roster ratings, not last year's record, are the number I'll check first. Also keep an eye on Seattle (Pythagorean 97-65, a 93-win team) as a candidate to rise.