The Dugout Nov 6, 2198 Help Sign in with Discord

← Dugout News

Beat column · Feb 25, 2198

Champs on Paper, Contenders on a Thin Margin: Cleveland's Spring Test

By Nadia Kovac

The Guardians swept the World Series, but the numbers say they were the ninth-best team in the league. Nadia Kovac on what spring training must fix before Opening Day.

The banner says champions. The trend line says be careful. Cleveland went 92-70, won the AL Robinson by a game over Seattle, then ran through Boston 3-1, Cincinnati 4-2 and Houston 4-0. That is a gorgeous October. It is also a title won by a team with a Pythagorean record of 83-79 and a Power Ranking of ninth, at 54.8.

The Gap Between 92 and 83

Nine wins of luck is a lot to hold onto. Boston's Pythagorean mark was 109-53, and Tampa Bay's was 100-62. Cleveland's own run differential suggests a .500-ish club that caught every bounce. I'm not taking the ring away. But GM Michael should not read a sweep of Houston as a license to coast, because regression does not care about parades.

The pitching core is the reason to stay calm. Bob Ward posted a 2.94 ERA, Roy Barker 3.35, and Ray Melton saved 44 games with a 2.00 ERA. Donald Bryant added a 1.90 ERA in relief. Here is the catch: Paul Long, Barker, Ward, Léo Charles, Drew Ashley and others are all free agents after 2198. Long led the club at 4.1 WAR. This is the last go-round for much of this staff, and Long is 29 strikeouts shy of 2,000. Ward is two wins from 100. Expect both milestones, and expect contract conversations to get loud.

The Shortstop Problem

Lyle McIntosh hit .169 with a .449 OPS and cost the team 0.6 WAR over 135 games. Quincy Molina was at minus 1.0 WAR. Andy Wills, a minus 1.5 WAR, posted a 5.05 ERA out of the pen. Meanwhile Doug Holt (4.4 WAR), Albert McCann (.295, 27 HR) and Forest Escobedo (.816 OPS) carry the lineup. A champion with a black hole at short is a champion hoping. Notably, Cleveland just called up Kyle Lawrence, a shortstop, from AAA. Watch whether he gets a real look.

The Callup Parade

On Feb 25 the Guardians promoted a dozen players from AAA, including center fielder Travis Roach, a 60 FV prospect ranked 179th, plus Floyd Blair, Forrest Chandler and Doug Butler. It reads like camp roster churn more than a plan. Still, it is the first sign of who might claw for a spot. Top prospects Bryce Neal (No. 70) and Thomas Brantley (No. 78) are not on that list yet.

What to Watch

First, who wins shortstop and left field. Second, whether Roach sticks. Third, whether the front office adds an arm or bat before spring training closes the free-agent window. Payroll sits at $118.1M, with just $24.0M committed to 2199, so the flexibility is there. Cleveland has Denver Chapman riding a 15-game hitting streak into the new year, which is a nice omen. I'd still bet on the club being good, not great, until the roster says otherwise.