Cardinals Straddle .500 as Spring Training Opens in St. Louis
By Walt Harmon
St. Louis finished 81-81, and the Power Rankings say the climb is real. Walt Harmon on a pitching staff in flux, a Pythagorean tease, and the last free agent window.
Spring training is here, and the St. Louis Cardinals open it exactly where they finished: 81-81, third-best in a middling NL Gibson, 17 games behind Tampa Bay. Respectable. Not the Cardinal way, but respectable.
The Numbers Say There's More Here
The Dugout Power Index has St. Louis 18th at 50.4, up six spots, and the Pythagorean record is 83-79, two wins better than the real thing. A roster rating of 54.9 sits above Albuquerque, Vancouver, and Oakland, all of whom the Cardinals sit ahead of or near. Edwin Atkinson led the lineup at 4.2 WAR with 23 homers and 20 steals, and Ricardo Lopez hit 29 homers with an OPS of .808 despite a .209 average. Adrian Pineiro added 27 homers and 87 RBI. That's a lineup with a spine. My opinion: the bats are fine. The question is the arms.
The Pitching Puzzle
Keith Harris posted a 2.33 ERA and still went 5-7, which is the kind of injustice that makes a traditionalist grind his teeth. Bo NDER (3.79 ERA, 137 strikeouts) is a free agent after 2198, and so is Orlando Chavez. Cardinals fans know that the GM, FBP, will have a decision to make on NDER sooner than later. Meanwhile, Dave Foster and NDER were both on the Power Rankings injury list at 14 days each, and on Feb. 25 the club busily activated Joe Thomas and Juan Garcia from the injured list. Thomas had a rough stretch on the injury ledger, with about 144 more days listed, so I'd watch how that plays out. Garcia carries about 54 days. A flurry of call-ups on opening day of camp, from Brandon Morris and Tiberiu Gheorghiu to catcher George Morgan and first baseman Chris Graham, reads like roster housekeeping rather than a master plan. Graham hit .152 in 17 games last year, so he has work to do.
Brad Crews (11-5, 3.13) and Hugo Grimaldi (3.07) are signed through 2199, which gives the staff a base. Still, Marlon Gaines's 4.68 ERA and Paul Meyer's negative WAR show the back end needs help.
Money and the Future
Payroll is $115.7M, with $72.3M already committed to 2199. That is real flexibility, and this is the final sim to sign free agents before the season. I'd like to see FBP spend a little of it on a veteran arm. The farm is promising too: Nicholas Green (No. 62 in the league), Cosmin Balba, Stuart Cooper, John Davis, and Richie Weilman all grade as FV 60.
What to Watch
Watch the free-agent market before it closes, who wins the rotation spots, and whether Thomas and Garcia stay healthy. If the pitching settles, this is a winning team.